They Just Don't Get Me: A Qualitative Analysis of Transgender Women's Health Care Experiences and Clinician Interactions

Abstract

Transgender individuals face many barriers when accessing health care, including having to teach clinicians how to care for them to receive appropriate care. We conducted a secondary analysis of qualitative data collected via semistructured interviews with 18 transgender women ranging in age from 21 to 60 years and living with HIV. Data were analyzed using conventional content analysis. Participants encountered two clinician types: Those who get me and Those who don't get me. Clinicians who get me provided gender-affirming care, fostered patient engagement, performed appropriate health screenings, and were willing to learn about transgender health. Clinicians who don't get me were aloof, uninterested, and unwilling to provide care. Clinicians who don't get me and system-level factors such as fragmented care, lack of insurance, and a low volume of transgender-competent clinicians contributed to transgender women's unmet health and education needs. Recommendations for improving transgender health care are provided.

Suicide among LGBTQIA+ youth: A review of the treatment literature

“…schools, hospitals, healthcare systems etc.). Such challenges are common to many TGD youth and their families (Berry, 2018;Hines et al, 2019). Second, although ABFT proved acceptable to caregivers, they were also experiencing significant stress and burden at the time of treatment.…”

A Review of the State of HIV Nursing Science With Sexual Orientation, Gender Identity/Expression Peoples

“…Nurses have opportunities to advocate for the development of best practices and policies that can reduce these disparities in health care access ( Thornhill & Klein, 2010 ). Clinical training and education on the health needs of transgender people needs to be improved ( Burton et al, 2021 ; Hines et al, 2019 ). Transgender peoples' experiences in health care are marked by stigmatizing and discriminatory practices, including not addressing and referring to individuals by their preferred name and pronouns.…”

“…Transgender peoples' experiences in health care are marked by stigmatizing and discriminatory practices, including not addressing and referring to individuals by their preferred name and pronouns. There is an urgent need to strive to normalize health care for transgender people, treating them with dignity and respect, and transition to gender-affirming clinical environments with gender-neutral restrooms and breast examination education for transgender women ( Hines et al, 2019 ; Munro et al, 2017 ). Nurses have the opportunity to align with the YP+10 principles through policy advocacy work to establish systemic policies and in many instances national policies and laws to protect the right to health and other human rights of transgender people ( Munro et al, 2017 ).…”

An Intervention by and for Transgender Women Living With HIV: Study Protocol for a Two-Arm Randomized Controlled Trial Testing the Efficacy of “Healthy Divas” to Improve HIV Care Outcomes

“…TWH face a complex array of psychosocial challenges that complicate their access and adherence to HIV care, such as limited access to and refraining from healthcare due to stigma and past negative experiences with providers, prioritization of gender-related healthcare, and concerns about adverse interactions between ART medications and hormone therapy. (21,22) Social and economic marginalization due to transphobia (negative societal attitudes toward transgender persons) often result in poverty and unstable housing, familial alienation, limited formal education, limited social support, mental illness, trauma and victimization, substance use, and introduction to sex work often at an early age (23)(24)(25)(26)(27)(28)(29). These factors can result in late or no presentation to HIV medical care and poor health outcomes (30).…”