Thin idealization and causal attributions mediate the association between culture and obesity stereotypes: An examination of Chinese and American adolescents

Abstract

Few studies have examined age or cultural differences in the stereotypes adolescents have of persons with obesity. The present research explored the hypotheses that American adolescents have more negative obesity stereotypes than Chinese adolescents and that the effects of culture are mediated by weight attributions and thin idealization. Participants (N = 335; 181 female; M age = 14.83 years, SD = 1.57 years) completed measures of thin idealization and causal attributions and made generalizations from and attributions of stereotypical personality characteristics to obese figures. Not only did stereotypes differ between countries, but generalizations of negative characteristics from obese figures increased with age. In addition, American adolescents more firmly endorsed the 'thin ideal' and were more likely to attribute obesity to internal causes that Chinese adolescents. As anticipated, between-country differences in stereotyping were mediated by thin idealization and causal attributions. Findings are discussed in terms of the 'doctrine of the mean', social identity theory, and dual-process theories. Statement of Contribution The development of obesity stereotypes has been the subject of a number of recent studies. Although scarce, research on adolescents' obesity stereotypes indicates that the strength of these stereotypes increases with age and that these increases are mediated by thin idealization and causal attributions. The current research adds to this growing literature that differences between Chinese adolescents' and American adolescents' obesity stereotypes - in terms of the assignment of stereotypical traits to people with obesity and the generalization of negative traits from an individual person with obesity to people with obesity as a group - are mediated by thin idealization and attributions about obesity's causes. The research also indicates that (1) age differences in obesity stereotyping vary as a function of the method used to measure stereotypes, (2) Chinese adolescents are less likely than American adolescents to attribute obesity to characterological flaws, and (3) American adolescents idealize thinness more than Chinese adolescents.

The Relationship Between SNS Usage and Disordered Eating Behaviors: A Meta-Analysis

“…Moreover, different cultures have different traditional aesthetics (Jankowiak et al, 2008 ). This may explain why, for example, research has shown that compared with Asian adolescents, American adolescents have a deeper internalization of the concept that “beauty is thin” (Leung et al, 2004 ; Marsh et al, 2007 ; Klaczynski and Felmban, 2019 ). Thus, it should be expected that studies on this subject from different regions may well provide different findings.…”

The relationship between the high-risk disordered eating and social network navigation among Saudi college females during the COVID pandemic

“…Different cultures have different traditional aesthetics. White American adolescents strongly internalize the concept that “beauty is thin.” Therefore, studies on this subject from different regions may yield different findings ( 61 ).…”

Anti-fat bias in secondary school teachers: Are physical education teachers more biased than mathematics teachers?

“…BMI was also used as a control variable, since most studies have found a negative association between PA and BMI in children and adolescents (Jiménez-Pavón et al, 2010). BMI, gender, and grade level were also considered as control variables in the prediction of anti-fat attitudes, since previous research has found associations between these variables in adolescent samples (Klaczynski and Felmban, 2019; Puhl et al, 2011).…”