Thinking critically about whole-grain definitions: summary report of an interdisciplinary roundtable discussion at the 2015 Whole Grains Summit

Abstract

Definitions for whole grain (WG) have been published by governments, the food industry, and grain organizations and generally fall into 2 categories: WG and WG food. WG definitions focus on the principal components of the WGs and their proportions, whereas WG-food definitions describe the quantity of WGs present in food. In the United States, widespread agreement exists on the main parts of a definition for a WG, with a definition for a WG food still in its early stages; a standard definition that has been universally accepted does not exist. Furthermore, nutrition policy advises consumers to eat WGs for at least one-half of their total grain intake (2010 and 2015 Dietary Guidelines for Americans), but confusion exists over which foods are considered WGs and how much is needed to achieve health benefits. In December 2014, a workshop sponsored by the subcommittee on collaborative process of the US Government's Interagency Committee on Human Nutrition Research convened in Washington, DC, and recognized WG definitions as a key nutrition and public health-related issue that could benefit from further collaboration. As a follow-up to that meeting, an interdisciplinary roundtable meeting was organized at the Whole Grains Summit on 25 June 2015 in Portland, Oregon, to help resolve the issue. This article summarizes the main opportunities and challenges that were identified during the meeting for defining WGs and WG foods internationally. Definitions of WGs and WG foods that are uniformly adopted by research, food industry, consumer, and public health communities are needed to enable comparison of research results across populations.Am J Clin Nutr 2016;104:1508-14.

Consumer attitudes and misperceptions associated with trends in self-reported cereal foods consumption: cross-sectional study of Western Australian adults, 1995 to 2012

“…Although dietary guidelines of most countries recommend whole-grain foods there is no universally accepted definition [12] making country comparisons challenging. Cereals, also known as grain foods [13], include breads, breakfast cereals, grains, and other products.…”

Compliance with the New 2017 Child and Adult Care Food Program Standards for Infants and Children before Implementation

“…Stakeholder concerns mirrored reported rates of compliance, except for the requirement for whole grains. Because of confusion over what constitutes a grain that is whole grain rich, 20,21 providers may have overreported compliance. Topics with relatively low compliance will likely require the most training and support.…”

The ABCs for Nutrition Poststroke: An Evidence-Based Practice Guide for Rehabilitation Professionals

“…The word whole refers to grains or whole-grain foods when they consist of all edible parts of the grain 16 after removal of inedible parts such as the hull and husk. 17 Refinement of grains to produce refined flour and refined grain products leads to loss of nutrients and fiber content and hence it is considered beneficial to eat whole grains or whole-grain foods. Table 2 lists general dietary suggestions that you can provide to help your patients understand general evidence-based dietary principles they can follow to prevent a secondary stroke.…”