‘This is ordinary behaviour’: Categorization and culpability in Hamas leaders’ accounts of the Palestinian/Israeli conflict

Abstract

The present paper examines the talk of three senior figures from the Palestinian Hamas political movement. Data are drawn from a series of journalistic interviews that were conducted in the months leading up to the invasion of Gaza by Israel in December 2007. Using membership categorization analysis, we explore the membership categories and category-bound attributes that interviewers use in questions about responsibility for potentially culpable actions and the ways that these are taken up, challenged, or reworked by interviewees in presenting their own versions. The analytic findings show that interviewers deploy categories bound up with terrorism while interviewees develop alternative categorizations of resistance. Interviewers construct Palestinians as victims of Hamas' actions while interviewees construct them as victims of Israeli aggression and international indifference. In warranting these alternative constructions, the interviewees contrast current behaviours of the international community with those of the past and align current Palestinian actions with those previously taken by Western nations in resisting illegitimate occupations. Through these descriptions of categories and actions, the interviewees attribute to the wider international community responsibility for addressing the events of the ongoing conflict.

“This is an EU crisis requiring an EU solution”: Nation and transnational talk in negotiating warrants for further inclusion of refugees

“…Flanagan introduces a broader set of actors than the EU, namely, “the international community” (line 5; cf. McKinlay, McVittie & Sambaraju, ) as those who are facing an extreme “migration challenge” (line 5). The extreme nature of the “challenge” is worked up through taking up the description of the reasons for migration offered by Durkan, namely, the “conflict in Syria—the biggest driver behind this year's migrant flows—has led to the world's largest humanitarian crisis” (lines 6–7), but also through a listing of other geopolitical areas.…”

“…national community" (line 5; cf McKinlay, McVittie & Sambaraju, 2011). as those who are facing an extreme "migration challenge" (line 5).…”

Denunciation and the construction of norms in group conflict: Examples from an Al‐Qaeda‐supporting group

“…In this extract, we see history again used as a resource for derogation. History (and ‘serial connectedness’ – Condor, ) is an important feature in debates about identity and political action (Condor, ; Lyons, ; for examples in Muslim politics see Hopkins et al ., ; McKinlay, McVittie, & Sambaraju, ). In the PIR mailings, the history of colonial rule in India, the Crusades, and the Inquisition were frequently used to denounce opponents.…”

Threat, Victimhood, and Peace: Debating the 2011 Palestinian UN State Membership Bid

“…The Palestinian leader represents Israel as the sole threat, while the Israeli leader constructs the Palestinian threat as being "embedded" within a superordinate Islamist/Iranian threat. Abbas' speech resonates with hegemonic societal discourses concerning the power imbalance between the Israelis and Palestinians, and the vulnerability of the Palestinians (McKinlay et al, 2011;Poller, 2012). Conversely, the Israeli Prime Minister contests such hegemonic societal discourses by positioning the Palestinian threat within discourses concerning militant Islam, and more recently Iranian nuclear aspirations (Poller, 2012).…”