Threshold Effect of Tourism Development on Economic Growth Following a Disaster Shock: Evidence from the Wenchuan Earthquake, P.R. China

Abstract

To examine whether tourism can effectively stimulate economic growth following a disaster shock, we apply a panel threshold regression technique to test the threshold effect of tourism development on economic growth of the 36 Wenchuan earthquake-affected counties in 2008-2016. The empirical results using the panel fixed-effects model show that tourism significantly contributes to economic growth, supporting the validity of the tourism-led growth hypothesis (TLGH) for the disaster-affected destinations. The results of the panel threshold regression model also indicate a threshold effect of tourism development on economic growth, implying that counties with different conditions of tourism specialization and industrial structure experience different impacts on the tourism-growth nexus. Specifically, the estimated coefficients of tourism on economic growth decrease with the levels of tourism specialization and industrial structure exceeding the threshold value. Based on the Tourism Area Life Cycle theory (TALC), we further divide the 36 disaster-stricken counties into six types based on the evolution of tourism specialization: Exploration-stage type, involvement-stage type, transition-stage type, development-stage type, consolidation-stage type, and stagnation-stage type. The empirical findings and managerial implications discussed are generally applicable to policymakers seeking new ways to invigorate the economy in other disaster-affected destinations.Note: Notice of the State Council of China on printing and distributing the general plan for recovery and reconstruction after the Wenchuan Earthquake announced the 39 disaster-stricken counties of the Sichuan province that were seriously affected by the Wenchuan earthquake. They include:

The Impact of Higher Education on Economic Growth in ASEAN-5 Countries

“…Hansen [37] mentioned that this F-test might not have a standard distribution; thus, he suggested using the bootstrap method to generate asymptotically first-order corrected p-values. Zhang and Cheng [47] mentioned that the p-value yielded from the bootstrap could be employed to validate the existence of a nonlinear relationship. Thus, in this study, we follow the traditional criteria; the null hypothesis of the kink effect is rejected if the p-value is less than the desired critical value, e.g., 0.10, 0.05, and 0.01.…”

The effects of air transportation, energy, ICT and FDI on economic growth in the industry 4.0 era: Evidence from the United States

“… Ghartey (2013) introduced a different perspective to capture structural changes with the effect of a natural disaster (hurricane) as it relates to tourism development. Similarly to Ghartey's research on natural disasters, the more recent study by Zhang and Cheng (2019) considered the effect of a significant earthquake on tourism development in several countries. Alexander et al.…”

“…Tourism is regarded as “the invisible part of export” ( Raspor et al., 2017 ) because there is no form of production to measure its impact on the growth of an economy. It is found to have a vital role in economic growth ( Zhang and Cheng, 2019 ). Economic growth can not only be aided by labour and capital increase but also by export expansion.…”

“…Hence, when compared to the export-led growth hypothesis, the TLGH similarly explains likely transient relationships that exist between economic growth and tourism activities in the long and short-run ( Brida et al., 2016 ; Etokakpan et al., 2019 ; Balsalobre-Lorente and Leitão, 2020 ). The theoretical framework for the TLGH was primarily postulated and proposed by Balaguer and Cantavella-Jordá (2002) , whose study indicated that development in tourism could only enhance economic growth in one way ( Zhang and Cheng, 2019 ).…”

Does the Level of Environmental Uncertainty Matter in the Effect of Returnee CEO on Innovation? Evidence from Panel Threshold Analysis

“…There are valuable, theoretical, and practical policy implications that emerge from the empirical results [52], from which scholars and managers can considerably benefit.…”