Through the Lens of Television: Progression in Portrayal of Pakistani Trans* Community (A study of TV shows from 2010 to 2018)

Abstract

This paper studies the representation of transgender in Pakistani television after a legal breakthrough of transgender laws in 2009. In this development, the Supreme Court of Pakistan provided identity rights to the oppressed trans* community. This study focuses on 24 transgender characters in five Pakistani Urdu TV shows (drama serials and telefilms) aired from 2010 to 2018. Following the research design of Capuzza and Spencer (2017), I employed the methodology of qualitative content analysis and coded 18-minute self-created mini-episodes for casting, visibility, identity, embodiment, and social isolation. My finding suggested that the visibility of transgender people is improved over the course of time in Pakistani Urdu TV shows. However, it does not apply across the spectrum of LGBTQ identities. Although the medium has started presenting transgender in a less conventional way and a verity in characterization is visible, they are still depicted in stigmatized and blue-collar jobs. The socially excluded hijra (bisexual) community is portrayed struggling for its basic human rights and respect. The trans* narrative of "Wrong body" is still the main discourse and reason of subjectivity. Narratives about homosexuality, which are considered contrary to the Islamic perspective, are absent. Mainly the TV shows represent the activism against trans* discrimination that disapproves the inequitable socioeconomic and moral practices and emphasizes basic equal rights for the transgender community.

Transgender Community in Pakistan: From Marginalized “aliens/others” to Empowered “Citizens”?

“…The main stream media became more sensitive and conscious of the status and condition of transgender community. As a result, the media industry mainly started to "represent the activism against transgender discrimination that disapproves the inequitable socio-economic and moral practices and emphasizes the basic equal rights for the transgender community" (Abbas, 2019 As a result of this inclusion, many transgender started to join media and entertainment industry. Marvia Malik (Hamdani, 2018) became the first transgender anchor while Kami Sid emerged as a supermodel.…”