To test the error catastrophe theory of aging we determined the error frequency of protein synthesis in several strains of cultured human fibroblasts at early and late passage. Error'rates were calculated from analysis of native and substituted actins on two-dimensional gels of cellular proteins after induction 9f mistranslation by histidine starvation in the presence of histidinol. Early-passage cells from fetal, young, and old donors and cells from subjects with the Hutchinson-Gilford and Werner syndromes of accelerated aging had similar error frequencies. Late-passage cells from fetal, young, and old normal donors had similar or lower'error frequencies than corresponding early-passage cells. No correlation was observed between error frequency, donor age, or maximal life span in vitro. We also examined an immot a cell line, simian virus 40-transformed WI38 fibroblasts. These cells had a significantly elevated rate of mistranslation (2.8 ± 0.2 X 10-4)(+ SEM) compared to their untransformed counterpart WI38 (0.6 i 0.1 X 10-4) or all diploid cells combined (1.1 + 0.1 X 10-4) Taken together, the data fail to support the error catastrophe theory of aging.The error catastrophe theory of cellular aging postulates that errors in protein synthesis lead to a protein synthetic machinery with progressively lower fidelity and to the eventual accumulation of a lethal proportion of aberrant proteins (1). A corollary of this hypothesis is that the abrogation of senescence by transformation of fibroblasts into permanent lines sbould be associated with a rate of translationialerrors that is lower than that of senescent cells.A major-difficulty in testing these predictions has been the lack of a rapid and direct measure of error frequencies in intact eukaryotic cells. Parker et al. (2) have developed a method in which the synthesis of error-containing proteins can be induced in bacterial and animal cells by amino acid starvation. They proposed that as a result of specific amino acid substitutions after starvation for particular amino acids, proteins were synthesized with altered isoelectric points. These proteins appeared on two-dimensional polyacrylamide gels as a series of satellite spots trailing the native protein spots in the isoelectric focusing dimension (2, 3), a phenomenon known as stuttering (2).We now describe the development of this system into a quantitative assay and its application to the measurement of error frequencies in various cultured human fibroblasts. Our findings are contrary to the error catastrophe theory of aging: error frequencies of late-passage cells and cells from old donors or subjects with progeria and Werner syndromes are not increased compared to early-passage cells from young donors whereas the error frequency of a simian virus 40 (SV40)-transformed permanent line is significantly increased. Table 1. "Early passage" denotes cultures with less than 50% of the life span completed (4) and with greater than 80% of cells capable of proliferation by the thymidine labeling index (13). "Late ...