“…Over the years several lines of research have attempted to replicate these studies through immunization of animals with crude tick saliva gland protein extracts (Brown et al, 1984, Shapiro et al, 1989, Nyindo et al, 1989, Banerjee et al, 1990, Kovar, 2004, Willadsen, 2006, Narasimhan et al, 2007, Jittapalapong et al, 2008) and since the 1990s with recombinant tick saliva proteins (Tsuda et al, 2001, Mulenga et al, 1999, You, 2005, Dai et al, 2009, Guo et al, 2009). The common practice in tick vaccine efficacy studies is to challenge infests immunized animals once (Tsuda et al, 2001, Mulenga et al, 1999, You, 2005, Dai et al, 2009, Guo et al, 2009, Galay et al, 2014).…”