Hypoxia Inducible Factor α (HIF-α) isoforms regulate key macrophage (Mϕ) functions during ischemic inflammation. HIF-2α drives pro-inflammatory cytokine production; however potential requirements for HIF-2α during other key Mϕ functions, including phagocytosis, are unknown. In contrast to HIF-1α, HIF-2α was not required for hypoxic phagocytic uptake. Surprisingly, basal HIF-2α levels under non-hypoxic conditions were both necessary and sufficient to suppress phagocytosis. Screening approaches revealed selective induction of scavenger receptor MARCO, which was required for enhanced engulfment. Chromatin IP identified the antioxidant NRF2 as directly responsible for inducing Marco. Concordantly, Hif-2α−/− Mϕs exhibited reduced antioxidant gene expression, and inhibition of mitochondrial reactive oxygen species (mROS) suppressed both Marco expression, and phagocytic uptake. Ex vivo findings were recapitulated in vivo, wherein the enhanced engulfment phenotype resulted in elevated bacterial clearance and cytokine suppression. Importantly, natural induction of Hif-2α by IL-4, also suppressed MARCO-dependent phagocytosis. Thus, unlike most characterized pro-phagocytic regulators, HIF-2α can act as a phagocytic repressor. This interestingly occurs in resting Mϕs through tempering of steady state mROS. In turn, HIF-2α promotes Mϕ quiescence by blocking a MARCO bacterial response pathway. IL-4 also drives HIF-2α suppression of MARCO, leading to compromised bacterial immuno-surveillance in vivo.