Analytic solutions to the time-dependent Schrödinger equation for cutoff wave initial conditions are used to investigate the time evolution of the transmitted probability density for tunneling. For a broad range of values of the potential barrier opacity α, we find that the probability density exhibits two evolving structures. One refers to the propagation of a forerunner related to a time domain resonance [Phys. Rev. A 64, 0121907 (2001)], while the other consists of a semiclassical propagating wavefront. We find a regime where the forerunners are absent, corresponding to positive time delays, and show that this regime is characterized by opacities α < αc. The critical opacity αc is derived from the analytical expression for the delay time, that reflects a link between transient effects in tunneling and the delay time.