Timely diagnosis of dementia? Family carers' experiences in 5 European countries

Abstract

Objectives Timely diagnosis of dementia is recommended in national strategies. To what extent is it occurring across Europe, what factors are associated with it, and what is the impact on carers emotions of quality of diagnostic disclosure? Methods/design Survey of family carers recruited through 5 Alzheimer's associations (Czech Republic, Finland, Italy, the Netherlands, and Scotland). One thousand four hundred and nine carers participated, 84% completing online. Fifty‐two percent were adult children, and 37% were spouses, with median age 57. Most (83%) were female. Results Nearly half (47%) of carers reported that an earlier diagnosis would have been preferable. Delaying factors included reluctance of the person with dementia, lack of awareness of dementia, the response of professionals, and delays within health systems. Recent diagnoses were no more likely to be considered timely, although professional responses appeared to be improving. Delayed diagnoses were more often reported by adult child carers and where the diagnosis was made in the later stages of dementia, or another condition had been previously diagnosed. In all countries except Italy, the diagnosis was shared with the person with dementia in the majority of cases. Timely diagnoses and higher quality diagnostic disclosure are associated with better adjustment and less negative emotional impact on carers in the short and medium term. Conclusions Although the study sample were well educated and likely to be in touch with an Alzheimer organisation, many continued to experience the diagnosis of dementia as coming too late, and further work on public awareness, as well as on professional responses, is needed.

Neuropsychological assessment and diagnostic disclosure at a memory clinic: A qualitative study of the experiences of patients and their family members

“…Reducing uncertainty could facilitate the start of the acceptance process in cases of cognitive impairment. This is in line with a recent study that showed that an early diagnosis with high quality diagnostic disclosure was associated with better adjustment and less negative emotional impact both in the short and the long term (Woods et al, 2019). In our study, patients without a cognitive impairment were relieved when they learned that the NPA was going well.…”

Vascular and metabolic risk factor differences prior to dementia diagnosis: a multidatabase case–control study using European electronic health records

“…For example, the length of time between dementia symptoms being noticed and diagnosis of dementia has been estimated to vary in Europe from 1.61 years in Italy to 2.49 years in Scotland and 2.57 years in Netherlands. 46 Therefore, comparisons are limited with epidemiological cohorts using dementia screening protocols. At least some of the widening difference in exposure levels between cases and controls may, therefore, have occurred during times when dementia was evident but undiagnosed.…”

Carers’ experiences of timely access to and use of dementia care services in eight European countries

“…The positive experiences reported by the majority of carers in this European sample appear to be an unusual finding in the literature, which largely reports barriers to service use. Furthermore, a recent study reported a lack of timely diagnosis of dementia and carers’ experiences of delays (Woods et al , 2018). The barriers reported in this study are in line with previous research reporting barriers to service use (Vetter et al ., 1998; Buono et al ., 1999; Brodaty et al ., 2005; Greenwood and Smith, 2015).…”