To Be or Not to Be Vaccinated? The Ethical Aspects of Influenza Vaccination among Healthcare Workers

Abstract

Influenza is a highly contagious airborne disease with a significant morbidity and mortality burden. Seasonal influenza (SI) vaccination has been recommended for healthcare workers (HCWs) for many years. Despite many efforts to encourage HCWs to be immunized against influenza, vaccination uptake remains suboptimal. Sometimes there is a significant sign of improvement, only if numerous measures are taken. Is ‘the evidence’ and ‘rationale’ sufficient enough to support mandatory influenza vaccination policies? Most voluntary policies to increase vaccination rates among HCWs have not been very effective. How to close the gap between desired and current vaccination rates? Whether (semi)mandatory policies are justified is an ethical issue. By means of a MEDLINE search, we synthesized the most relevant publications to try to answer these questions. Neither the ‘clinical’ Hippocratic ethics (the Georgetown Mantra: autonomy, beneficence, non-maleficence, and justice), nor the ‘public health’ ethics frameworks resolve the question completely. Therefore, recently the ‘components of justice’ framework was added to the ethical debate. Most options to increase the uptake arouse little ethical controversy, except mandatory policies. The success of vaccination will largely depend upon the way the ethical challenges like professional duty and ethics (deontology), self-determination, vaccine hesitance, and refusal (‘conscientious objector’) are dealt with.

Public Knowledge, Attitudes, and Practices toward Seasonal Influenza Vaccine in Saudi Arabia: A Cross-Sectional Study

“…However, several challenges face the GVAP goal to increase the voluntary vaccination against influenza, particularly vaccine hesitancy. This has been faced with almost all vaccines before, such as diphtheria-tetanus-pertussis and hemophilus influenza [ 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 , 9 ]. Even in light of the recent COVID-19 pandemic, many remain skeptical and intend to abstain from voluntary vaccinations based upon myths, misinformation, and/or safety concerns [ 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 , 14 ].…”

Seasonal Influenza and Low Flu Vaccination Coverage as Important Factors Modifying the Costs and Availability of Hospital Services in Poland: A Retrospective Comparative Study

“…This phenomenon is common for many European countries, where the majority medical students and medical doctors declare very positive general attitudes toward vaccinations, but they rarely support them with behaviors and vaccinate themselves [ 27 ]. The literature data suggest that in cases of healthcare workers, multiple factors need to be dealt with in this context, including professional duty and ethics, the need for self-determination, vaccine hesitance, or even conscientious refusal [ 28 ]. The higher staff absenteeism due to illness led to organizational problems, a heavier work burden on the remaining employees during a challenging period (resulting from additional requirements for more isolation and care of patients with confirmed influenza).…”

What Is the State-of-the-Art in Clinical Trials on Vaccine Hesitancy 2015–2020?

“…The exponential growth of chronic non-communicable diseases is challenging for the sustainability of health sector in both developed and developing countries [ 14 , 15 , 44 , 68 ], which reinforce the need of maintain high vaccination ratios in both regions. In addition, vaccine hesitancy and vaccination ratios need to be optimized at a global level, especially because of COVID-2019 pandemic.…”