“…These studies include (Boutabba, 2014;Jamel & Maktouf, 2017;Li, Zhang, & Ma, 2015;Ozturk & Acaravci, 2013;Saboori, Sulaiman, & Mohd, 2012;Zhang, 2011), while some studies found a negative relationship between financial development and CO2 emissions. These studies include (Mulali, Tang, & Oztur, 2015;Saidi & Mbarek, 2017;Xing, Jiang, & Ma, 2017). In the fourth stage, financial development and industrial production positively contribute to economic growth (Ang, 2008;Kedourie, 2013;Lakhera, 2016;Malinvaud, 1979;Sent a, 1966;Shucheng, 2017;Swanson & Lin, 2009) .…”