Tobacco-Related Counseling and Documentation in Adolescent Primary Care Practice: Challenges and Opportunities

Abstract

Introduction Primary care visits present an opportunity to reduce tobacco use and tobacco smoke exposure (TSE) among adolescents. To date, few studies have examined tobacco-related electronic health record (EHR) documentation in adolescent visits. The purpose of this study was to (1) describe tobacco-related EHR documentation practices in adolescent care clinics, including whether alternative tobacco products, parental use, and TSE were addressed; and (2) identify aspects of adolescent tobacco use that may inform EHR updates and counseling and documentation practices. Methods Following a convergent mixed-methods design, we conducted an EHR review of 508 adolescent well-child visits, performed focus groups with pediatric providers and staff, and conducted in-depth interviews with adolescent patients. Record review data and interview transcripts were analyzed and interpreted concurrently. Results In the EHR review, cigarette screening was documented in 92.3% of visits, smokeless tobacco screening in 51.4%, parental tobacco use in 23.2%, and home TSE in 33.1% of visits. Smoking status options were not mutually exclusive and did not include noncigarette products. No records documented assessment of e-cigarette use, despite nearly half of adolescent interview respondents citing these as the most popular products among adolescents. In interviews, adolescents discussed their experiences with alternative tobacco/nicotine products more than cigarettes. Conclusions Tobacco use status prompts should be revised for clarity and include noncigarette tobacco products and TSE. Provider education on noncigarette products and TSE assessment is needed. Improvements in EHR systems, resources, and tools can lead to better tobacco screening, prevention, and treatment practices among primary care providers. Implications Clinical guidelines call for pediatricians to assess and treat adolescent and parental tobacco use during primary care visits. The use of electronic health records (EHRs) can improve screening and counseling practices; however, few studies have examined tobacco-related EHR documentation practices in adolescent care settings. This mixed-methods study found low rates of EHR documentation related to noncigarette nicotine/tobacco products, parental tobacco use, and tobacco smoke exposure. These results demonstrate the need for increased provider training and EHR modifications to facilitate comprehensive tobacco control efforts in the adolescent population.

Evaluation of tobacco screening and counseling in a large, midwestern pediatric emergency department

“…The current study was the first step in a study to develop and test a comprehensive tobacco treatment program at this hospital. Our results align with studies of pediatric healthcare providers, which also reported similar barriers to conducting tobacco screening and counseling 14,32 . Additionally, our study had low representation of racial/ethnic minorities.…”

Youth vaping: a review and update on global epidemiology, physical and behavioral health risks, and clinical considerations

“…Screening tools for youth EC use have not yet been developed and validated, but questions about EC use can be easily integrated into existing assessment methods [ 87 ]. The absence of electronic medical record prompts for the assessment of EC use has been identified as an area requiring attention in adolescent primary care visits [ 88 ]. Table 2 offers items to consider for assessment based on available evidence [ 1 , 19 , 87 ].…”

Health problems and health care requirements of the population affiliated to Tuzla Aydınlı Primary Care Centre

“…Birinci basamakta bireysel bilgilendirmenin erişkin dönemde tütün kullanımını engellemesine yönelik çalışmalara rastlanmamış olmakla birlikte periyodik muayeneler sırasında sigara kullanımının sorgulanması, zararları hakkında bilgilendirilmesi ve bireye tütün ürünlerini kullanıyorsa bırakması yönünde danışmanlık verilmesi aile hekimliğinin rutin bir uygulaması olarak önerilmektedir. (9)(10)(11) Tuzla EASM'de ise 18 yaş ve üzeri bireylerde sigara kullanım oranı %17,5 (n=28) iken, sigara ve tütün kullanımının zararları hakkında bilgilendirilme oranı %25,6 (n=41)'dır.…”