Too tired to care? The psychological effects of working with trauma

Abstract

This quantitative and qualitative longitudinal study was designed to examine the effects on caregivers working therapeutically with seriously traumatized people. The participants were 13 healthcare workers seconded into a trauma and recovery team (TRT) set up to help those traumatized by the Omagh bombing on 15 August 1998. Quantitative data were collected using the Compassion Satisfaction/Fatigue Test and the Life Status Review Questionnaire. Qualitative data regarding positive and negative aspects of working with traumatized individuals, as well as caregiver's experience leaving the TRT, were gathered using open-ended questions contained in the final data set. These questionnaires were completed at four points in time: August 1998, December 1998, August 1999 and February 2001. Ethical approval for the study was gained from the Sperrin Lakeland Trust research committee. Analysis of the quantitative data indicated that levels of compassion fatigue and burnout increased, respectively, from 18.85 to 34.46 and 22.38 to 29.69 over the first year. Levels of compassion satisfaction decreased from 87.62 to 80.15, while levels of satisfaction with life (53.85 to 40.38) and life status (11.23 to 5.62) also decreased. Findings also demonstrated that compassion satisfaction is possibly a protective factor against compassion fatigue and burnout, in that caregivers with high compassion satisfaction scores were less likely to have corresponding high compassion fatigue and burnout scores. Findings from the qualitative data generated, revealed that team spirit and camaraderie, along with the satisfaction of seeing clients recover, were the most positive aspects of working in the team. Media interest, coping with and containing anger shown by bereaved relatives and dealing with the content of client's stories were the most negative. Themes to emerge from leaving the team included lack of understanding and support from non-trauma managers and an underestimation of the impact on caregivers of finishing in the team. Strategies that were found to be beneficial in helping to alleviate the negative effects of working with trauma were also elicited. This research has implications for practice, management and education.

“A rewarding conclusion of the relationship”: staff members’ perspectives on providing bereavement follow-up

“…Seeing patients improve has been cited by health care workers as one of the most rewarding aspects of their jobs [8], and the absence of this makes working with terminally ill patients particularly difficult. In fact, caring for dying patients has been linked to stress, burnout and professional grief [33] [42].…”

Caring International Research Collaborative: A Five-Country Partnership to Measure Perception of Nursing Staffs’ Compassion Fatigue, Burnout, and Caring for Self

“…Literature was found for compassion fatigue in Ireland (Collins & Long, 2003), Israel (Berger & Gelkopf, 2011), and New Zealand (Brankin, 2010). Brankin's article addressed the importance of compassion fatigue but did not conduct original research, which left two articles that identified compassion fatigue in the countries of study.…”

Compassion Fatigue, the Wellness of Care Providers, and the Quality of Patient Care

“…Emotional exhaustion (9) Depersonalization (5) Personal Accomplishment (8) Involvement ( Likewise, the role of negative qualities like self-sacrificing behavior and negligence of selfnurturing behavior still needs to be better understood (Sabo, 2011). Gaining knowledge on qualities that predispose or prevent CF will pave the way for effective interventions that help…”