The prevalence of cyclopropanes in biologically active compounds has fueled many investigations into their preparation. Despite significant advances, more efficient methods for their catalytic enantioselective synthesis remain in demand. Previously, we reported a novel tandem approach to diastereo‐ and enantioenriched cyclopropyl alcohols. Our method involved an initial asymmetric C–C bond formation by addition of organozinc reagents to aldehydes catalyzed by a (−)‐MIB‐based catalyst. The resulting allylic zinc alkoxides were then subject to directed cyclopropanations. Although this approach provided cyclopropyl alcohols with very high enantio‐ and diastereoselectivity, it was successful with only aliphatic aldehydes. Aryl aldehyde substrates, on the other hand, exhibited low conversion and variable diastereomeric ratios. The present study is aimed at raising the stereoselectivity and yield of the aforementioned tandem reaction with aryl aldehyde substrates to make the method synthetically useful. Herein, we report the successful optimization of aryl aldehyde substrates in our one‐pot tandem approach leading to cyclopropyl alcohols with high yields and enantio‐ and diastereoselectivities. Copyright © 2012 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.