Toward a feminist political ecology of household food and water security during drought in northern Nicaragua

Abstract

Few studies assess the relationship between food and water access, despite global concerns about people's inability to maintain access to both food and water. We conducted a mixed-methods comparative case study in northern Nicaragua, with smallholders from two neighboring communities that differed in water availability and institutional strength, using a feminist political ecology framework and food and water security definitions that focus on access, availability, use, and stability. We adopted a participatory approach that included: a sex-disaggregated survey in 2016; interviews, participant observation, and community-based water quality testing from 2014 to 2019; and analysis of a severe drought that occurred from 2014 to 2017. Our results suggest that uneven power relations, biophysical conditions, gender, and institutions shape food and water access, and indicate that households across both communities average 2 months of drinking water insecurity during the dry season followed by an average of 2.5 months of food insecurity early in the growing season. The average duration of lean food months was similar across communities and sex, but water insecurity lasted longer in the community that had weaker local institutions and less surface water availability. Ethnographic research helped to document uneven and gendered experiences of water access and to illustrate how they were also shaped by conflicts over water for irrigation vs. domestic uses and cross-scalar limitations in water and land governance. Although we found that gender and institutions were not strong predictors of several food and water insecurity indicators on their own, both factors influenced the terms of access, conflict, and cooperative governance needed to secure resources and well-being. Our study highlights the need for theory, methods, and field research that integrate the analysis of food and water security, and it contributes to developing a feminist political ecology approach that unifies this analysis with a focus on gender.

Gender identities, water insecurity, and risk: Re‐theorizing the connections for a gender‐inclusive toolkit for water insecurity research

“…But in doing so, it also then reproduces existing notions of femininity and masculinity as they relate to water. We note that while some ethnographic studies acknowledge gender fluidity around water roles (e.g., Bacon et al, 2021), fluidity is rarely the object of study. As such, it has been noted that, given the fluidity of both gender norms, roles, and water conditions, a primary set of questions to be interrogated includes how these are given the appearance of fixity and stability, despite their inherent fluidity over space and time (Harris, 2006).…”

Protecting Nature: Religious Ecofeminism in Indigenous Women’s Movements

“…What happens to women and nature is not only rooted in the "innate" relationship between women and nature that many have come to accept. It is also embedded in structural and material inequalities (Bacon et al, 2022). Climate change is increasingly presented as a security issue; this "climate security" discourse arguably gives a greater sense of urgency to the already alarming climate crisis.…”