Toward a ‘Migrant Trap’? Local Development, Urban Sustainability, Sociodemographic Inequalities, and the Economic Decline in a Mediterranean Metropolis

Abstract

After years following the breakdown of the Great Recession in Europe, crisis-driven urban shrinkage can be adequately investigated considering changes over time in selected demographic indicators, with a specific focus on migration. Using official statistics and a literature review, the present study documents the inherent demographic decline in metropolitan Athens (Greece) as a response to economic stagnation after a long-lasting expansion. The empirical results of our study delineate metropolitan shrinkage in Southern Europe as a process associated with complex socioeconomic conditions leading to (possibly counterintuitive) demographic outcomes as far as migration trends are concerned. Recession has determined unsustainable economic conditions especially for non-native population segments, promoting both class and ethnic segregation. The negative migration balance in the 2010s led to an intense population decline hitting settlements made already demographically fragile because of low fertility and aging. Athens became a sort of ‘migrant trap’, being progressively unattractive for incoming migration flows—both internal and international—and losing an increasingly high number of non-native residents settling in the area, especially during the ‘gold’ decade of the 2004 Olympics. A sudden reduction in immigration rates reflected both economic (recession) and non-economic (population aging, fertility reduction, and childbearing postponement) factors, causing an incipient shrinkage after secular urban growth. The empirical results of our study add to the traditional literature on ‘industrial cities shrinkage’ in Europe and contribute to (re)formulate short- and medium-term development scenarios in large agglomerations, shedding further light on the role of migration in crisis-driven processes of urban decline in Mediterranean Europe.

Income Inequality in the Over-Indebted Eurozone Countries and the Role of the Excessive Deficit Procedure

“…However, as opposed to the Greek model, the increase in WSPY-1(IT) was associated with a sudden increase in income inequality. This result seems counterintuitive, given that an increasing labour share is usually considered a driver of income equalization (Ciommi et al 2022 ). Following the seminal works by Karabarbounis and Neiman ( 2014 ), Piketty and Zucman ( 2014 ) and Dao et al ( 2017 ), a vast literature on job income share has documented its continuous decline worldwide.…”

The Contribution of Immigrants to Urban Economies: Exploring Citizens' Opinions in Athens, Greece

“…Immigration is a major issue contemporary societies deal with, with negative implications for both the source country -losing population and labor force -and the host country (Ciommi et al, 2022). By analyzing the shift from mechanical to organic solidarity in 'The Division of Labor in Society', which detailed the division of labor in its contemporary forms (Zeković & Maričić, 2020), Durkheim (1893Durkheim ( in 2019 demonstrated how shared values and solidarity served as the foundation for social cohesiveness and integration of immigrants characteristic of any contemporary society.…”

Identification of the social economic and environmental context of the concept of city sustainability, based on the example of Ternopil, Ukraine

“…Caputo et al (2023) discuss the benefits of community gardens in post-earthquake recovery and during economic downturns. M. Ciommi et al (2023) show how population dynamics affect policy measures related to urban sustainability and metropolitan resilience. A.C. Ferrari et al (2023) analyse how digitalization transforms agriculture and rural spaces and reduces urban dependency.…”