Toward a more ‘sovereign’ Europe? Domestic, bilateral, and European factors to explain France’s (growing) influence on EU politics, 2017–2022

Abstract

In recent years, both inside and outside France, scholars and policymakers have emphasized a small and declining French influence on European politics and the political direction of the European Union (EU). By contrast, in 2022, at the end of President Emmanuel Macron’s first term in office, the EU increasingly follows French preferences and ideas. We argue that this renewed French clout is due to the interplay of factors located at different levels of government: a centralized political system and careful preparation of policy objectives at the domestic level, together with a more balanced bilateral relationship with Germany and several exogenous shocks hitting the EU, enabled the French President to upload national policy priorities to the European level. We combine a longer-term perspective, which considers the formulation and pursuit of national strategies, with moments of crisis altering the EU’s status quo and leading member states to promote change. We demonstrate France’s influence on EU politics based on developments in three policy fields, namely fiscal policy, competition policy, and defense industrial policy.

The Ideational Power of Strategic Autonomy in EU Security and External Economic Policies

“…According to an interviewee, there was 'no agreed definition of what SA is or what it is supposed to entail' (#3). Associated with French strategic thinking and interests, other member states continued to reject the use of the concept regarding the operational aspects of defence policy (Bora and Schramm, 2023). As summarised by Tocci (2021, p. 21), '[t]heir discomfort is driven by the belief that European strategic autonomy in defence is both a dangerous illusion and a concentration of intra-European power in a few (French) hands'.…”

The New Role of the European Commission in the EU’s Security and Defence Architecture: entrepreneurship, crisis and integration

“…For instance, have the various EU officials and diplomats been directly involved in the negotiations or working groups, or are they drawing their information from other sources? Moreover, as underlined by Bora and Schramm (2023), it is necessary to be 'aware of the methodological risks when focusing on primary sources, and on elite interviews in particular, [and] we [need to] triangulate our data with secondary academic literature on the respective topics'. Triangulation of the data (i.e.…”