Toward community‐inclusive data ecosystems: Challenges and opportunities of open data for community‐based organizations

Abstract

The benefits of open data for helping to address societal problems and strengthen communities are well recognized, and unfortunately previous studies found that smaller communities are often excluded from the current data ecosystem because of existing technological, technical, cognitive, and practical barriers. This study aims to investigate the process of communitiesʼ data use for community development and decision‐making—focusing on the opportunities and challenges of data for communities. From the interviews with 25 staff from community‐based organizations (CBOs) in nine small, medium, and large cities in the United States, the findings of this study describe dataʼs role in supporting communitiesʼ development while reporting several major challenges that hinder CBOs data use: difficulty accessing data, limitations of open data (un‐local nature, excluding essential data from being open), limited data capacity (especially in data literacy skills), and difficulties using and accessing existing data infrastructures. Our findings suggest opportunities for addressing these challenges, particularly by creating educational programming, building partnerships within data ecosystems, and bringing community voices forward in current data ecosystems, which are critical to realizing dataʼs potential for all citizens.

Human‐superviseddata science framework for city governments: A design science approach

“…Thus, capturing the complex social environments in structured data is challenging. In addition, valid interpretation of the results requires the understanding of both the data and the context (Janssen et al, 2017; Matheus et al, 2018; Yoon & Copeland, 2020). When the context is not considered in the data science process, it may lead to a presumption that “the world is understandable with numbers and math” (Mayer‐Schönberger & Cukier, 2013, p. 97).…”

A Review of Documentation: A Cross-Disciplinary Perspective

“…Digitalisation has brought the revolution of an "e-government" ethos across the globe on a larger and more intensive scale, where people obtain their administrative needs or access transparent and updated data through a dedicated online website or platform, providing a timely and efficient pathway for information and data collection. A growing number of international and governmental financial institutions invest in open data in developing countries to support their ongoing commitment to economic development [84].…”

“…Legislation about use, transmission and control over what appears on the internet lags behind technological innovations, which may have ethical implications [11] (p. 110). Moreover, despite the fact that decisions at all levels have become more datadriven, not all stakeholders have equal access to data, especially to open data, due to costs and literacy [84].…”

Building Capacity for Library Participation in Open Civic Data Work with the Civic Data Education Series

“…Open civic data initiatives have been steadily growing in number and support, with governments and community organizations increasingly making civic data available through data portals. However, while the availability of civic data has grown, not all community members know how to access this data or feel equipped to leverage it (Yoon & Copeland, 2020). Twidale et al (2013) argue that the growth of available data calls for a simultaneous growth of the public's data skills, with information professionals playing "critical" roles "as teachers, facilitators and intermediaries in data literacy interactions" (p. 247).…”