Toward Youth Friendly Services: A Survey of Young People in Primary Care

Abstract

BACKGROUND:The World Health Organization encourages the development of youth friendly services, yet little is known on how youth currently present in general practice. OBJECTIVE:To describe the perspectives, expectations, and service receipt of young people presenting to family doctors to inform the development of youth friendly services. DESIGN:Cross-sectional survey. PARTICIPANTS AND MEASUREMENTS:Consecutive young people attending 26 randomly selected practices were recruited in the waiting rooms. Standardized instruments were used to interview them before their consultation. RESULTS:Of 501 young people who were approached, 450 participated (91% participation rate). Most had respiratory (26%) or dermatological complaints (18%). When asked to assess their health status, 59% perceived they had neither a physical nor a mental illness. However, 43% stated they had fears about their health problem and 1 in 5 feared it could be life-threatening. Although only 10% presented with psychological complaints, 24% perceived they currently had a mental illness. The most common expectations were treatment (50%) and good communication (42%). Most youth were prescribed medication (60%), but 40% of those who received a prescription had not expected to receive a treatment. A follow-up appointment was offered to 57% of participants.CONCLUSIONS: This study identifies a gap between young people's perception of illness and their presentations to family doctors. It also highlights unexpected fears, and a mismatch between expectations and service receipt. These findings have implications for family medicine training and for clinical practice. They should inform the development of youth friendly services.

Brief intervention addressing excessive cannabis use in young people consulting their GP: a pilot study

“…Indeed there was a slightly higher proportion of female participants than described in previous studies of young people attending primary care (in which about two-thirds of young patients are female). 29,46 The GPs involved in the study may have had a tendency to see more female patients than is the case in other practices.…”

“…28 These consultations offer an ideal point of contact between young people and health professionals. 29,30 A brief intervention was successful in reducing cannabis use in a college setting. 31 Researchers in a pilot test of an intervention addressing substance use in ambulatory care met unexpected difficulties in recruiting patients for their study.…”

“…This is in line with previous research and suggests young people welcome participation in research that addresses problems that affect them. 29,44 That the survey was kept confidential and that young people could consent to participation without asking their parents may also have favoured this high participation rate and avoided an unwelcome selection bias. 45 All the GPs involved in the pilot test worked in urban settings, and all but one worked in single-or two-doctor practices.…”

What is the role of general practice in addressing youth mental health? A discussion paper

“…In exploring why young people with psychological symptoms do not present to GPs, perceived they currently had a mental illness and while 60% received a prescription, only 40% had expected this intervention 51 .…”

Un service de santé adapté pour les jeunes: pourquoi ce concept et comment l'appliquer?

“…Dans la mesure où la majorité des jeunes voient un médecin de famille (médecin généraliste, interniste ou pédiatre) au moins une fois par année, les médecins de famille sont particulièrement bien placés pour répondre aux besoins de santé des adolescents et jeunes adultes [4][5][6][7][8][9]. Les jeunes ont cependant tendance à consulter pour des problèmes somatiques courants (problèmes respiratoires, dermatologiques) alors que la principale morbidité et mortalité à cet âge est liée à des problèmes de santé mentale ou de comportement [3,10]. L' OMS souligne les caractéristiques essentielles des services dont les jeunes ont besoin dans cette période unique de transition vers l'âge adulte (voir tab.…”