Towards an interactive, process‐based approach to understanding range shifts: developmental and environmental dependencies matter

Abstract

Many species are undergoing distributional shifts in response to climate change. However, wide variability in range shifting rates has been observed across taxa, and even among closely‐related species. Attempts to link climate‐mediated range shifts to traits has often produced weak or conflicting results. Here we investigate interactive effects of developmental processes and environmental stress on the expression of traits relevant to range shifts. We use an individual‐based modelling approach to assess how different developmental strategies affect range shift rates under a range of environmental conditions. We find that under stressful conditions, such as at the margins of the species’ fundamental niche, investment in prolonged development leads to the greatest rates of range shifting, especially when longer time in development leads to improved fecundity and dispersal‐related traits. However, under benign conditions, and when traits are less developmentally plastic, shorter development times are preferred for rapid range shifts, because higher generational frequency increases the number of individual dispersal events occurring over time. Our results suggest that the ability of a species to range shift depends not only on their dispersal and colonisation characteristics but also how these characteristics interact with developmental strategies. Benefits of any trait always depended on the environmental and developmental sensitivity of life history trait combinations, and the environmental conditions under which the range shift takes place. Without considering environmental and developmental sources of variation in the expression of traits relevant to range shifts, there is little hope of developing a general understanding of intrinsic drivers of range shift potential.

Temperature drives pre‐reproductive selection and shapes the biogeography of a female polymorphism

“…In Europe, I. elegans occurs from Cyprus, Greece, Italy and Spain in the south to Scandinavia in the north (Gosden et al ; Askew ). Southern populations of I. elegans are multivoltine with several generations per year, whereas populations in northern Europe are generally univoltine, with only one generation per year (Parr ; Shama et al ; Fitt et al ). I. elegans is characterised by three female‐limited colour morphs, one of which is typically a male mimic (Fig.…”

Exploring larval phenology as predictor for range expansion in an invasive species

“…A key question is about the future expansion in both invaded ranges. Our analysis does not consider the role of ecoevolutionary processes (Sexton et al 2009, Donelson et al 2012, Shama et al 2014, in particular local adaptation (Hassall et al 2008, Angert et al 2011, Peterson et al 2019 that may explain some mismatches between observations and species distribution models (Fitt et al 2019). We accounted for intraspecific variation in thermal responses through the incorporation of random terms of the model into the estimations of WLR.…”

Increased duration of extreme thermal events negatively affects cold acclimation ability in a high-latitude, freshwater ectotherm (Ischnura elegans; Odonata: Coenagrionidae)

“…Finally, exposure to stressful temperatures, especially over long durations, may weaken the ability of individuals to respond adaptively, resulting in maladaptive effects of prior thermal exposure at long ex-phenotypes have improved and gained in adaptive plasticity in cold stress towards the range edge (Lancaster et al, 2015(Lancaster et al, , 2017aWood et al, 2019), and changes in HSP allele frequencies have also shifted towards the range edge in response to temperature gradients (Dudaniec et al, 2018). Understanding how this well-studied species responds to changes in the duration of stressful thermal priming events, in terms of adaptive or maladaptive adjustments to its acclimation capacity, will help develop spatiotemporal estimations for shifts in thermal tolerance and distributional shifts in this and other species (Sánchez-Guillén et al, 2016;Fitt et al, 2019), when taking changes in the duration of different extreme weather events into account.…”