Tracing the Emergence of Design Problems and Their Impacts on the Complexity of Engineering Solutions

Abstract

The design of ITER, a large-scale nuclear fusion reactor, is intertwined with profound research and development efforts. Tough problems call for novel solutions, but the low maturity of those solutions can lead to unexpected problems. If designers keep solving such emergent problems in iterative design cycles, the complexity of the resulting design is bound to increase. Instead, we want to show designers the sources of emergent design problems, so they may be dealt with more effectively. We propose to model the interplay between multiple problems and solutions in a problem network. Each problem and solution is then connected to a dynamically changing engineering model, a graph of physical components. By analysing the problem network and the engineering model, we can (1) derive which problem has emerged from which solution and (2) compute the contribution of each design effort to the complexity of the evolving engineering model. The method is demonstrated for a sequence of problems and solutions that characterized the early design stage of an optical subsystem of ITER.

Challenges Of Big-science: A Matrix-based Interface Model To Manage Technical Integration Risks In Multi-organizational Engineering Projects

“…The matrix visualization gives powerful insight in the complexity and risks, and the model-based workflow makes for a flexible approach. The textual ESL specifications are easy to edit and process, so that any architectural changes due to unanticipated problems would automatically lead to an updated MDM (Beernaert et al, 2021).…”

“…It is important to realize, however, that this is only an indication of progress. Interfaces may need updates while they remain on the same IRL, or new interfaces may appear because of unforeseen architectural design changes (Beernaert et al, 2021). Such effects are not captured in the proposed 𝑃𝐼.…”