“…These were the bulge dwarfs by Bensby et al (2013), the red giant stars from Alves-Brito et al (2010) that were carried out in the optical for the same stars as in Meléndez et al (2008), Cunha & Smith (2006), Ryde et al (2010), Rich et al (2012), Johnson et al (2014), Rich & Origlia (2005) and Fulbright et al (2007). Zoccali et al (2006), N, O abundances are from Friaça & Barbuy (2017 We now compare the present oxygen abundances for the GIRAFFE sample together with those from the UVES sample, given in FB17, compared with: a) the reanalysis of stellar parameters carried out by Jönsson et al (2017) for 23 stars of the same UVES data, for which they derived oxygen abundances, except for one of them (B3-f1) that FB17 did not include in their study; b) Ryde et al (2010) where five stars of our UVES sample were included, plus another six stars; c) recent results by Schultheis et al (2017), where comparisons with a fraction of the present stars were given; d) recent results for microlensed dwarf stars by Bensby et al (2017). ] values for model changes of ∆T eff = 150, 200 K, ∆log g = +0.2, 0.4, ∆v t = +0.1, 0.2, 0.3 km s −1 , for UVES and GIRAFFE data respectively, and corresponding total error, applied to the stellar parameters T eff , log g, [Fe/H], v t of stars BW-b6 (4200 K, 1.7, −0.25, 1.3 km.s −1 ), and B6-b3 (4700 K, 2.0, 0.10, 1.6 km.s −1 ).…”