Trajectories of Change in Anxiety Severity and Impairment During and After Treatment With Evidence-Based Treatment for Multiple Anxiety Disorders in Primary Care

Abstract

Background Coordinated Anxiety Learning and Management (CALM) is a model for delivering evidence-based treatment for anxiety disorders in primary care. Compared to usual care, CALM produced greater improvement in anxiety symptoms. However, mean estimates can obscure heterogeneity in treatment response. This study aimed to identify (1) clusters of participants with similar patterns of change in anxiety severity and impairment (trajectory groups); and (2) characteristics that predict trajectory group membership. Methods The CALM randomized controlled effectiveness trial was conducted in 17 primary care clinics in 4 US cities in 2006–2009. 1,004 English- or Spanish-speaking patients age 18–75 with panic, generalized anxiety, social anxiety, and/or posttraumatic stress disorder participated. The Overall Anxiety Severity and Impairment Scale was administered repeatedly to 482 participants randomized to CALM treatment. Group-based trajectory modeling was applied to identify trajectory groups and multinomial logit to predict trajectory group membership. Results Two predicted trajectories, representing about two-thirds of participants, were below the cut-off for clinically significant anxiety a couple of months after treatment initiation. The predicted trajectory for the majority of remaining participants was below by nine months. A small group of participants did not show consistent improvement. Being sicker at baseline, not working, and reporting less social support were associated with less favorable trajectories. Conclusions There is heterogeneity in patient response to anxiety treatment. Adverse circumstances appear to hamper treatment response. To what extent anxiety symptoms improve insufficiently because adverse patient circumstances contribute to suboptimal treatment delivery, suboptimal treatment adherence, or suboptimal treatment response requires further investigation. Clinical Trial Registration clinicaltrials.gov Identifier: NCT00347269

Predictors of anxiety recurrence in the Coordinated Anxiety Learning and Management (CALM) trial

“…A prior study examining the CALM cohort similarly found that being unemployed was associated with inconsistent partial symptom improvement (Joesch et al, 2013). Furthermore, our results fit well with numerous studies identifying higher rates of stress and psychiatric disorders in low SES patients (Abravanel and Sinha, 2014; McLeod and Kessler, 1990; Muntaner et al, 2004) .…”

Patterns of Change in Response to Prolonged Exposure: Implications for Treatment Outcome

“…Although these data indicate clear heterogeneity in patient responding, critical evaluation suggests that profiles derived from raw symptom scores may more strongly reflect differences in initial PTSD severity as opposed to variability in patterns of change per se. Furthermore, person‐centered techniques employed in existing research are generally ill equipped to isolate response trajectories that deviate from continuous mathematical functions (e.g., those involving rapid symptom fluctuations) …”

“…Furthermore, person-centered techniques employed in existing research are generally ill equipped to isolate response trajectories that deviate from continuous mathematical functions (e.g., those involving rapid symptom fluctuations). [44] Given these considerations, the current study reviewed archival records to evaluate heterogeneous profiles of recovery in veterans receiving PE through a specialty VAMC clinic. Latent profile analyses (LPA) of change in weekly symptom data (i.e., deviation from initial score) were used to identify discontinuous trajectories of responding across 10 weeks of intervention.…”

The pattern of symptom change during prolonged exposure therapy and present-centered therapy for PTSD in active duty military personnel

“…For some conditions, linear change best described a given class; for others, a hyperbolic, quadratic, or higher-order polynomial change appeared to best characterize change. This provides further justification for using LPA in lieu of other computational methods that assume homogeneous patterns of change across classes (Joesch et al ., 2013). Further consideration of the underlying process of change in class membership is necessary.…”