Trans Masculinity: Comparing Trans Masculine Individuals’ and Cisgender Men’s Conformity to Hegemonic Masculinity

Abstract

Introduction Masculinity and masculine norms are still relevant in the current social context. Literature showed that some masculine norms could be considered protective health buffers, while traditional masculinity has negative consequences on men’s behaviors, relationships, and health. Methods In the present study, we aimed at investigating trans masculine and cisgender men’s levels of adherence to different dimensions of hegemonic masculinity. A total of 200 participants (100 trans masculine people and 100 cisgender men) took part in the study. Results Results exhibit that trans masculine individuals showed higher scores than cisgender men on the dimensions of emotional control and self-reliance, whereas cisgender men showed higher endorsement of norms such as heterosexual self-presentation and power over women. Conclusions Results are discussed in light of the minority stress model and masculinity threat theory. Policy Implications The present work should act as a reminder of the pressure that trans masculine people may feel to conform to certain aspects of hegemonic masculinity. This may have the adaptive function of protecting them from the discrimination and threats that they expect from others.

“I Don’t Want to be a Girl. I Am a Girl!” Experiences Before, During and After Transition in Families with Trans Children and Adolescents

“…Explicit self-disclosure and name choice are considered to be among the main triggers of transition (Ehrensaft, 2020). Previous researchers found that name choice is one of the main issues in the trans community (Anzani et al, 2022), similar to our findings. In some of our cases, the initial disclosure of identity occurred at a very early age (4 years), while in other cases it occurred much later (16 years).…”

Conformity to Masculinity Norms and Mental Health Outcomes Among Gay, Bisexual, Trans, Two-Spirit, and Queer Men and Non-Binary Individuals

“…To claim masculinities, trans men often exhibit actions traditionally associated with being a man ( Phillips & Rogers, 2021 ). The pressure to perform and pass as masculine may be a safety strategy to avoid trans-related violence and aggression ( Abelson, 2014 ; B. F. Harrison & Michelson, 2019 ; Lee & Kwan, 2014 ) and may reflect a response to heightened anxiety caused by expected prejudiced events ( Anzani et al, 2022 ). Thus, in our study, the pressure to perform and pass as typically masculine may reflect a safety strategy that reduced the potential for more lethal forms of masculinity—aggression and violence toward those deemed not masculine or, worse still, feminine.…”

Desire for Genital Surgery in Trans Masculine Individuals: The Role of Internalized Transphobia, Transnormativity and Trans Positive Identity

“…Participants were recruited through a web-based survey as part of a larger study aimed at investigating different aspects of the experiences of trans masculine individuals with masculinity. [ 30 ] The study’s inclusion criteria were: (1) being a trans masculine person; (2) being at least 18 years old; (3) and living in Italy for at least 10 years. Recruitment entailed identifying groups on social media (Facebook and Instagram), whose members might be interested in participating in a study, dealing with topics related to the LGBTQ+ community or specifically to the trans community.…”