Trends over time in the size and quality of randomised controlled trials of interventions for chronic low-back pain

Abstract

Purpose Previous reviews of randomised controlled trials (RCTs) for low-back pain (LBP) have failed to identify any positive trend in study quality with more recent years of publication. This study aimed to identify and describe trends over time in the study design characteristics and risk of bias in chronic LBP trials performed over the past 30 years. Methods One fifty-seven randomised trials of interventions for chronic LBP were extracted from recently published systematic reviews. The reviews included RCTs on physical and rehabilitation interventions, injection therapy and denervation procedures, complementary and alternative therapies and pharmacological interventions for chronic LBP. Study level data were extracted and analysed for trends associated with year of publication.Results Overall, the mean sample size in the RCTs was 141 (median 70; range 17-3093). There was a slight increase in the median number of risk of bias criteria fulfilled from trials published prior to 1995 to those published after 1996. The analysis showed that in more recent years RCTs of medical interventions were more likely to be successfully blinded than RCTs of non-medical interventions. Conclusions The continuing uncertainty regarding the efficacy of many interventions for chronic LBP again stresses the need for large RCTs with low risk of bias. Further research is needed into specific risks of bias within the RCTs for chronic LBP and the effect they have on the plausibility of the results.

Cognitive-behavioral management training of depressive symptoms among inpatient orthopedic patients with chronic low back pain and depressive symptoms: A 2-year longitudinal study

“…However, although comparable to results reported by Schweikert et al [14], showing 5.4 days of sick leave less in the experimental group than in the control group with the standard rehabilitation 6 months after rehabilitation, this finding should be interpreted with caution due to the reduced sample size. However, in line with previous research (for a review, see [32]), these results point to the cost-effectiveness of the newly developed cognitive-behavioral management training, but further evidence is needed.…”

A systematic review finds variable use of the intention-to-treat principle in musculoskeletal randomized controlled trials with missing data

“…Henschke et al [30] reported the trend over time (1980e2008) in the quality of 157 RCTs of interventions for chronic low back pain. Their evaluation was based on 11 criteria described by Koes et al [31], of which two are closely linked to the ITT principle.…”

The use of functional neuroimaging to evaluate psychological and other non-pharmacological treatments for clinical pain

“…Physiotherapy and exercise-based interventions for the management of chronic pain are widely recommended and have proven effective in reducing pain and improving physical function in a variety of pain syndromes, including FM [80], back pain [61], arthritis [79], and many others. These treatments take a variety of forms, from one-on-one sessions with a licensed physiotherapist, to group aquatherapy sessions, to prescription of stretching and muscle-strengthening exercises at home.…”