“…However, the great amount of experimental data on 9CB exhibits something puzzling about the character of its SmA-to-N phase transition. Some data allow for a character either tricritical or even first order in nature. ,,, Other data exhibit a crossover second-order transition with critical exponents near its tricritical value. ,,,, Even a few years ago, some of the authors of this paper measured the specific heat of 9CB, pure and mixed with other related liquid crystals, obtaining controversial results about the SmA-to-N critical behavior. In addition to these results, Halperin, Lubensky, and Ma , published a theory, denoted as HLM theory, according to which the SmA-to-N transition should always be weakly first-order in nature.…”