Dimethylsulfoniopropionate (DMSP) is produced by a wide variety of marine phytoplankton, and it can be enzymatically cleaved to dimethylsulfide (DMS) and acrylate by DMSP lyases. DMS formation in the sea plays an important role in the global sulfur cycle, yet the factors regulating production of DMS are poorly understood. We evaluated various procedures used for in vitro assays of DMSP lyase activity (DLA) of cells captured on filters. We also compared in vitro DLA from plankton material collected from diverse water samples, as well as from cultures of different phytoplankton species. The type of filter used to collect plankton material affected the apparent in vitro DLA, with glass fiber filters (Whatman GF/F) yielding higher rates than polycarbonate filters. Treatment of filtered plankton with Tris buffer (200 mM in 500 mM NaCl), with vigorous mixing, appeared to permeablize cells allowing maximal DLA. We found that buffer pH and dithiothreitol (DTT) affected DLA positively or negatively depending on the phytoplankton species or water sample tested. In general, natural seawater plankton and cultured dinoflagellates had higher DLA with higher pH buffers (pH range 6.5 -8.5). In contrast, the prymnesiophytes Emiliania huxleyi and Phaeocystis antarctica had higher in vitro DLA at lower pH (pH range 6.5 -8.5), and DTT and Triton X-100 significantly increased the apparent enzyme activities. Not all phytoplankton contained detectable DLA, and DLA varied greatly among strains of the same species. DLA was however, detectable in all samples of particulate materials collected from a wide range of marine surface waters, including those from the coastal Gulf of Mexico, North Atlantic and Southern Ocean, and these samples showed patterns of high Chl a normalized DLA where high irradiances and low nutrients occur. Consistent with this observation, the phytoplankton cultures isolated from such environments also showed high DLA. Thus, light and nutrients may be important factors determining DLA. However, not all the variations in DLA were explained by light and nutrients, and these variations may be due to the different functions of DMSP lyases such as osmotic regulation, anti-grazing, and antioxidant activity.