Tuberculosis cluster in an immigrant community: case identification issues and a transcultural perspective

Abstract

Summaryobjectives In a low incidence area for tuberculosis (TB), a computerized database identified an unusually high proportion of patients coming from one single country between 2004 and 2006. To determine whether they constituted a cluster, whether clustering was due to recent transmission, and to understand what undermined the efficacy of the contact tracing procedure, we conducted a retrospective study of all patients with TB from this country.methods Mycobacterium tuberculosis isolates of 15 TB cases originating from the same country over a 2½ year period were analysed by restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) and ⁄ or Rep-PCR. To identify links between patients, we revisited the social worker's files, cross-matched contacts' databases, and performed internet searches. A cultural evaluation was conducted by an anthropologist and an expert physician, through patient and community key informant interviews and a literature review.results Genotyping confirmed that 11 of 15 patients had identical isolates. Additional data revealed an unsuspected complex network of social links between 9 of these 11 patients. The transcultural evaluation pointed out the major obstacles to efficient contact tracing, such as importance of social stigma related to TB, differences in communication style and health beliefs, and linguistic barriers.conclusion The combined finding of identical genotypes and important social links between patients confirmed the suspicion of a TB cluster due to recent transmission. The cultural evaluation helped to explain the difficulties encountered during the contact tracing procedure, and offered strategies to improve its efficacy despite the magnitude of the social stigma attached to TB in this community.

Tuberculosis in Migrant Populations. A Systematic Review of the Qualitative Literature

“…Some studies highlighted that immigrants often initially played-down the importance of symptoms, to later self-diagnose and self-medicate, using pharmacies or private clinics and finally public healthcare centres [41,42]. The absence of symptoms despite contact with persons infected with TB led migrants to pay little attention to prevention or screening [21,27]. …”

Assessment of stigma associated with tuberculosis in Mexico

“…15,16 Van Rie and colleagues noted that the cross-cultural generalizability of TB and HIV/AIDS stigma scales used in Thailand may be limited. 17 They further hypothesized that the difference in the concept of stigma across cultural contexts is more refective of ‘nuances and degree rather than substance’.…”

Missed Opportunities for Tuberculosis Screening in Primary Care

“…We hypothesized that factors such as cultural or language barriers, difficulties returning to clinic, and stigma associated with tuberculosis could have contributed to incomplete LTBI screening. 23–25 In the adjusted models, parent language was not significantly associated with adherence to LTBI screening recommendations. However, children whose parents speak primarily Arabic had more completed LTBI screenings in unadjusted models and approached significance in one of the adjusted models.…”