Mutations in the genes that encode α- and β-tubulin underlie many neurological diseases, most notably malformations in cortical development (MCD). In addition to revealing the molecular basis for disease etiology, studying such mutations can provide insight into microtubule function, and the role of the large family of microtubule effectors. In this study, we use budding yeast to model one such mutation – Gly436Arg in α-tubulin, which is causative of MCD – in order to understand how it impacts microtubule function in a simple eukaryotic system. Using a combination of in vitro and in vivo methodologies, including live cell imaging and electron tomography, we find that the mutant tubulin incorporates into microtubules, causes a shift in α-tubulin isotype usage, and dramatically enhances dynein activity, which leads to spindle positioning defects. We find that the basis for this latter phenotype is an impaired interaction between She1 – a dynein inhibitor – and the mutant microtubules. In addition to revealing the natural balance of α-tubulin isotype utilization in cells, our results provide evidence of an impaired interaction between microtubules and a dynein regulator as a consequence of a tubulin mutation, and sheds light on a mechanism that may be causative of neurodevelopmental diseases. [Media: see text] [Media: see text] [Media: see text] [Media: see text] [Media: see text]