“…The situation is quite unsatisfactory and difficult to explain because (i) the purpose of Q-switching is to reach peak powers much higher than in a CW regime, (ii) such pulse durations are much longer than previously reported with active Q-switching of Tm,Ho:YLF [11], and (iii) from theoretical considerations and experiments on active Q-switching, Ho-lasers are considered to have much higher potential in this temporal regime than Tm-lasers [1]. Moreover, since excellent results in terms of output energy, pulse duration, and peak power have been obtained with in-band pumping of PQS Ho:YAG lasers by a Tm-fiber [12] and by a Tm:YLF laser [13] as well as for singlefrequency operation of a Tm-fiber laser pumped PQS Ho:YLF laser [14], the question arises of whether the poor performance reported in [5][6][7][8][9][10] is not related to the complex dynamics in the Tm,Ho-co-doped laser system at high inversion rates.…”