We have investigated the reduction of CO 2 to CO mediated by the anionic niobium nitride complex [NNb(N t BuMe) 3 ] − , a model complex of [NNb(N t BuAr) 3 ] − , using density functional theory. We mainly calculated the energetics for the interesting reaction sequence, reported recently by Cummins and his co-workers, involving reactions of the anionic niobium nitride complex [NNb(N t BuAr) 3 ] − with CO 2 to first give a carbamate complex. The carbamate complex then reacts with MeC(O)Cl to give an isocyanate−acetate, which can be reduced by SmI 2 to give the isocyanate complex (OCN)Nb(N t BuAr) 3 . Further reduction of the isocyanate complex by Na/Hg extrudes CO and regenerates [NNb(N t BuAr) 3 ] − . In addition, we compare the reaction pathways for the reduction reaction of the isocyanate complexes (OCN)M(N t BuMe) 3 (M = Nb, V), model complexes of (OCN)M(N t BuAr) 3 , with sodium and explain why these two reduction reactions give remarkably different products.
■ INTRODUCTIONCarbon dioxide (CO 2 ) is an easily available, renewable carbon resource. Therefore, there is significant interest in developing efficient transformation of CO 2 into useful chemicals. 1 However, cleavage of the CO bond(s) in carbon dioxide is not easy to achieve because of its high thermodynamic stability. A number of approaches to the transformation have been discussed in detail in a recent review article. 2 Of these approaches, many transition-metal complexes were found to be efficient in converting CO 2 to other chemicals. 3−10 In particular, (PNP)IrH 2 , 11 Li 2 [W(CO) 5 ], [WCl 2 (PMePh 2 ) 4 ], 12,13 (NHC)Ni (NHC = N-heterocyclic carbene), 14 L t-Bu Fe−N 2 − FeL t -B u (L t -B u = 2,2,6,6-tetramethyl-3,5-bis-[(2,6-diisopropylphenyl)imino]hept-4-yl), 15 [Cp 2 TiCl] 2 , Cp 2 Zr(II)-(CO) 2 , 16 Ir 2 (CO) 3 (dmpm) 2 , 17 [(Ph 2 P(CH 2 ) 2 PPh 2 ) 2 Rh]-[MgCl], 18 and a coordinatively unsaturated tris-aryloxide uranium(III) complex [(L)U] (L = 1,4,7-tris(3,5-di-tert-butyl-2-hydroxybenzylate)-1,4,7-triazacyclononane) 19 have been found to be capable of abstracting CO or O from CO 2 to form strong metal−carbonyl or metal−oxygen bonds. However, formation of strong metal−carbonyl or metal−oxygen bonds from these abstraction reactions represents a challenge to catalytic turnover. Recent studies showed that a sequence of reactions constituted a cycle for CO 2 reduction to CO when Zr(III)−O− Cu(II) 20 or [NNb(N t BuAr) 3 ] − (1Nb) 21−23 was employed. These metal complexes are believed to be promising for a catalytic reduction of CO 2 to CO.In this work, we are interested in the reaction sequence elegantly reported recently by Cummins and his co-workers (Scheme 1) involving the anionic niobium nitride complex 1Nb. 21 Scheme 1 shows that an initial binding of CO 2 to the terminal nitride nitrogen atom of 1Nb rather than the niobium metal center gives the carbamate complex 2Nb. Reaction of the