Two Is Best? The Persistence of a Two‐Child Family Ideal in Europe

Abstract

How persistent and universal has the two child family ideal been in Europe during the last three decades? We analyze responses of women of reproductive age from 168 surveys conducted in 37 countries in 1979–2012. A two‐child ideal has become nearly universal among women in all parts of Europe. Countries that used to display higher ideal family size have converged over time toward a two‐child model. Six out of ten women in Europe consider two children as ideal, and this proportion is very similar in different regions. The mean ideal family size has become closely clustered around 2.2 in most countries. Gradual shifts can be documented toward more women expressing an ideal of having one child (and, quite rarely, having no children) and a parallel decline in an ideal of three or more children. An increasing number of European countries saw their mean ideal family size falling to relatively low levels around 1.95–2.15. However, with the exception of one survey for eastern Germany and two of the surveys not included in our study owing to high nonresponse or low sample size, none of the analyzed surveys suggests a decline in mean ideal family size to levels considerably below replacement, i.e., below 1.9 children per woman.

Childlessness in Europe: Reconstructing Long-Term Trends Among Women Born in 1900–1972

“…According to Beck (1992: 116), "the ultimate market society is a childless society." Such an alarmist perspective can, however, be countered by pointing to the low shares of survey respondents who declare that childlessness is their reproductive ideal (Miettinen and Szalma 2014;Sobotka and Beaujouan 2014; see also Kuhnt et al,Chap. 11,in this volume).…”

Deseabilidad y planificación de la fecundidad adolescente en América Latina y el Caribe: Tendencias y patrones emergentes

“…730) plantean que la distinción convencional es entre las preferencias reproductivas, por una parte, y las intenciones y expectativas reproductivas, por la otra. Las primeras se relacionan con lo que las personas responden cuando se les consulta por lo que desean o quieren en materia de cantidad de hijos y momento de tenerlos, mientras que las segundas se relacionan con la búsqueda o no de un embarazo, sea próximo Se han llevado a cabo muchos estudios sobre las preferencias reproductivas, tanto en países desarrollados como en desarrollo (Sobotka y Beaujouan, 2014;Kodzi, Johnson y Casterline, 2010). Estos estudios han establecido que hay una correspondencia considerable entre las intenciones anteriores de tener más hijos y la fecundidad posterior.…”

“…La mayoría de estos estudios encontraron que las actitudes anteriores tenían un efecto independiente y estadísticamente significativo sobre la fecundidad, que superaba el de otros determinantes. Sin embargo, hoy en día hay un amplio debate sobre la utilidad real de esta variable, sobre todo por el marcado contraste que supone la mantención relativa de las preferencias o los ideales reproductivos en torno a los dos hijos, en países donde la fecundidad se ha desplomado y ha pasado a ser ultrabaja (Sobotka y Beaujouan, 2014).…”

Global Sustainable Development priorities 500 y after Luther: Sola schola et sanitate

“…The differentials are particularly pronounced in countries during the process of demographic transition, when death rates have already fallen and birth rates start to fall after a certain time lag (59). Only in recent years in the Nordic countries does the gradient seem to flatten or show a mild U-shape because more educated women can arrange their lives better in a way to actually achieve the two-child norm, which is still almost universal in Europe (60). More generally, the empowering effect of education brings women in high-fertility settings to want fewer children and find effective ways to have fewer children.…”