Beyond their contribution as fundamental building blocks of life, branched‐chain amino acids (BCAAs) play a critical role in physiologic and pathologic processes. Importantly, BCAAs are associated with insulin resistance, obesity, cardiovascular disease, and genetic disorders. However, several metabolome‐wide studies in recent years could not attribute alterations in systemic BCAAs as the sole driver of endocrine perturbations, suggesting that a snapshot of global BCAA changes does not always reveal the underlying modifications. Because enzymes catabolizing BCAAs have a unique distribution, it is plausible that the tissue‐specific roles of BCAA‐catabolic enzymes could precipitate changes in systemic BCAA levels, flux, and action. We review the genetic and pharmacological approaches dissecting the role of BCAA‐catabolic enzyme dysfunctions. We summarized emerging evidence on BCAA metabolic intermediates, tissue specificity of BCAA‐catabolizing enzymes, and crosstalk between different metabolites in driving metabolic maladaptation in health and pathology. This review substantiates the understanding that tissue‐specific dysfunction of the BCAA‐catabolic enzymes and accumulating intermediary metabolites could act as better surrogates of metabolic imbalances, highlighting the biochemical communication among the nutrient triad of BCAAs, glucose, and fatty acid.—Biswas, D., Duffley, L., Pulinilkunnil, T. Role of branched‐chain amino acid–catabolizing enzymes in intertissue signaling, metabolic remodeling, and energy homeostasis. FASEB J. 33, 8711–8731 (2019). http://www.fasebj.org