bThe formation of bacterial spoilage communities in food is influenced by both extrinsic and intrinsic environmental factors. Although many reports describe how these factors affect bacterial growth, much less is known about interactions among bacteria, which may influence community structure. This study investigated interactions among representative species of bacteria isolated from vacuum-packaged (VP) beef. Thirty-nine effectors and 20 target isolates were selected, representing 10 bacterial genera: Carnobacterium, Pseudomonas, Hafnia, Serratia, Yersinia, Rahnella, Brochothrix, Bacillus, Leuconostoc, and Staphylococcus. The influence of live effectors on growth of target isolates was measured by spot-lawn agar assay and also in liquid culture medium broth using live targets and effector cell-free supernatants. Inhibition on agar was quantified by diameter of inhibition zone and in broth by measuring detection time, growth rate, and maximum population density. A number of interactions were observed, with 28.6% of isolates inhibiting and 4.2% promoting growth. The majority of Pseudomonas isolates antagonized growth of approximately one-half of target isolates. Two Bacillus spp. each inhibited 16 targets. Among lactic acid bacteria (LAB), Carnobacterium maltaromaticum inhibited a wider range of isolates compared to other LAB. The majority of effector isolates enhancing target isolate growth were Gram-negative, including Pseudomonas spp. and Enterobacteriaceae. These findings markedly improve the understanding of potential interactions among spoilage bacteria, possibly leading to more mechanistic descriptions of bacterial community formation in VP beef and other foods.
The shelf-life of meat is influenced, in part, by the composition and levels of bacteria within the spoilage community (1). Independent laboratories have confirmed relatively high microbial diversity at the time of meat packaging, and showing a progressive shift to lower community complexity toward the end of shelf-life (2-4). For refrigerated vacuum-packaged (VP) beef, over time and under best-practice conditions, lactic acid bacteria (LAB) tend to predominate and, to a lesser extent, Enterobacteriaceae (5).Such change in bacterial community structure is based on intrinsic and extrinsic factors, including temperature, atmosphere, pH, and organic acids, all of which may influence growth (5, 6). However, the underlying forces of microbial interactions may also be important in shaping biodiversity of communities (7-10); such studies have received relatively little attention in foods. Bacteria interact in any given ecological niche through different mechanisms, including quorum sensing, contact-dependent inhibition, and nutrient competition, and via production of defense compounds such as bacteriocins, antibiotics, and organic acids (10-14). There have been numerous reports exploring the effectiveness of protective cultures and related antibacterial compounds at enhancing food safety and extending shelf-life (15-18); however, few have investigated int...