Two Sides of Emotion: Exploring Positivity and Negativity in Six Basic Emotions across Cultures

Abstract

We employ a novel paradigm to test whether six basic emotions (sadness, fear, disgust, anger, surprise, and happiness; Ekman, 1992) contain both negativity and positivity, as opposed to consisting of a single continuum between negative and positive. We examined the perceived negativity and positivity of these emotions in terms of their affective and cognitive components among Korean, Chinese, Canadian, and American students. Assessing each emotion at the cognitive and affective levels cross-culturally provides a fairly comprehensive picture of the positivity and negativity of emotions. Affective components were rated as more divergent than cognitive components. Cross-culturally, Americans and Canadians gave higher valence ratings to the salient valence of each emotion, and lower ratings to the non-salient valence of an emotion, compared to Chinese and Koreans. The results suggest that emotions encompass both positivity and negativity, and there were cross-cultural differences in reported emotions. This paradigm complements existing emotion theories, building on past research and allowing for more parsimonious explanations of cross-cultural research on emotion.

A Multimodal Exploration of Engineering Students' Emotions and Electrodermal Activity in Design Activities

“…On the other hand, other negative emotions including anger and anxiety may increase an individual's desire to prevent future failure and facilitate analytical, detail‐oriented styles of processing of information (Pekrun, ). Sometimes emotions can be self‐reported as having both positive and negative valence depending on the experience (An, Ji, Marks, & Zhang, ). For example, an individual who is motivated to pursue happiness may become depressed, miserable, and unhappy while doing so (Gruber, Mauss, & Tamir, ).…”

Measuring Engagement in Robot-Assisted Autism Therapy: A Cross-Cultural Study

“…Culture also influences expressiveness of emotions (Immordino-Yang et al, 2016). There are rather consistent patterns across Eastern and Western cultures, although differences also exist across cultures, and sometimes even within cultures (An et al, 2017;McDuff et al, 2017). Recently, Lim (2016) explored cultural differences in emotional arousal level between the East and West, focusing on the observation that high arousal emotions are valued and promoted more than low arousal emotions in the West.…”

Understanding parents’ emotional experiences for neonatal education: A narrative, interpretive approach

“…What this study also adds is a consideration of the different types of emotions that parents report. Classifying emotions according to whether they are positive or negative is congruent with a traditional approach where emotions are categorised dichotomously, as unpleasant or pleasant, activated or deactivated, as explained by An, Ji, Marks, and Zhang (). Andries () also outlines four main positive emotions (joy, happiness, gratitude and well‐being) and four main negative emotions (anger, fear, envy and jealousy), all of which occurred to some degree through the whole parent data set of this study.…”

“…Andries () also outlines four main positive emotions (joy, happiness, gratitude and well‐being) and four main negative emotions (anger, fear, envy and jealousy), all of which occurred to some degree through the whole parent data set of this study. However, An et al () point to this mode of classification being difficult to reconcile with more current views on emotion that do not consider a single continuum from positive to negative arguing that each emotion contains some degree of both negativity and positivity. It was deemed fitting, therefore, to follow this principle in the current study.…”