“…However, U and Th concentrations in the zircon are much higher than that of most mantle zircons analysed to date Hamilton et al, 1998;Heaman et al, 1990;Katayama et al, 2003;Kinny and Dawson, 1992;Kinny and Meyer, 1994;Kinny et al, 1989;Konzett et al, 1998Konzett et al, , 2000Konzett et al, , 2013Liati et al, 2004;Robles-Cruz et al, 2012;Schärer et al, 1997;Simonetti and Neal, 2010;Spetsius et al, 2002;Zheng et al, 2006). The only exceptions are: i) zircons from mantle xenoliths studied by Rudnick et al (1999), which contained U and Th concentrations up to 3950 and 3300 ppm, respectively, and were assumed to be inherited grains from recycled crustal rocks; and ii) zircons in mantle pyroxenites from the Hannouba alkali basalts (China), which have U and Th contents up to 23 000 and 16 500 ppm, respectively, and were attributed to carbonate metasomatism (Liu et al, 2010).…”