UK ethnicity data collection for healthcare statistics: the South Asian perspective

Abstract

BackgroundEthnicity data collection has been proven to be important in health care but despite government initiatives remains incomplete and mostly un-validated in the UK. Accurate self-reported ethnicity data would enable experts to assess inequalities in health and access to services and help to ensure resources are targeted appropriately. The aim of this paper is to explore the reasons for the observed gap in ethnicity data by examining the perceptions and experiences of healthy South Asian volunteers. South Asians are the largest ethnic minority group accounting for 50% of all ethnic minorities in the UK 2001 census.MethodsFive focus groups, conducted by trained facilitators in the native language of each group, recruited 36 South Asian volunteers from local community centres and places of worship. The topic guide focused on five key areas:1) general opinions on the collection of ethnicity, 2) experiences of providing ethnicity information, 3) categories used in practice, 4) opinions of other indicators of ethnicity e.g. language, religion and culture and 5) views on how should this information be collected. The translated transcripts were analysed using a qualitative thematic approach.ResultsThe findings of this Cancer Research UK commissioned study revealed that participants felt that accurate recording of ethnicity data was important in healthcare with several stating the increased prevalence of certain diseases in minority ethnic groups as an appropriate justification to improve this data. The overwhelming majority raised no objections to providing this data when the purpose of data collection is fully explained.ConclusionsThis study confirmed that the collection of patients' ethnicity data is deemed important by potential patients but there remains uncertainty and unease as to how the data may be used. A common theme running through the focus groups was the willingness to provide these data, strongly accompanied by a desire to have more information with regard to its use.

Accuracy of routinely recorded ethnic group information compared with self-reported ethnicity: evidence from the English Cancer Patient Experience survey

“…Therefore, in principle, the generalisability of the findings (particularly regarding younger patients) might be limited; equally, the need for accurate recording of ethnicity among cancer patients has been identified 23. We were also unable to explore potential inaccuracies in ethnicity categorisation resulting from longitudinal person-level discordance among patients with more than one hospital care episode.…”

“…Improvement in the quality of HES data (which is generally desirable26) should also encompass improvements in the quality of ethnicity coding. Qualitative studies have found a willingness among ethnic minority groups to provide this information,27 and future research should explore optimal ways for efficiently obtaining current self-reported information on ethnicity in patient records.…”

Monitoring migrant health in Europe: A narrative review of data collection practices

“…In the United Kingdom, for example, the communities largely established through migration from former colonies after the Second World War and subsequent waves of immigration are referred to as "black and minority ethnic" (BME) groups [34]. However, ethnicity-based data alone cannot be used to ascertain migrant status.…”

Role of Data in Improving Care within a Health System: A Case Study of the Australian Health System

“…The first has to do with collection -even though the healthcare industry has been lagging behind other business areas in the adoption of information technology, healthcare systems are now collecting enormous amounts of data (known as "Big Data"); the US healthcare system collects an estimated exabyte (or a billion gigabyte) of data each year [122] [130]. Addressing both these issues will help increase the usability of these data for a wider number of activities for a larger number of stakeholders.…”