Rarely, is there an opportunity to study and directly observe the same migratory animal across both breeding and nonbreeding seasons. In a rare, documented case, we highlight a live reencounter of a female Setophaga ruticilla (American Redstart) on its nest during the breeding season—an individual that was originally captured and tagged on its nonbreeding territory in Jamaica more than 3,250 km away. Advances in tracking technology allow researchers to track the movements of smaller organisms at higher resolutions. While tracking data alone have provided critical advances in the ecology of migratory animals, especially small migratory birds, there are exciting opportunities to move beyond tracking and to deeply explore biological questions about migratory animals by locating and directly studying (e.g., direct observation and physical sampling) the same individuals across the year. Although we have had the ability to precisely track large-bodied migratory birds (>100 g) for decades, researchers have rarely used these data to localize and directly observe or sample them across the year. Ultimately, we must consider the potential advances to be made in avian ecology through this endeavor. To this end, we highlight several specific areas of research that we believe move beyond tracking and can only be addressed by integrating direct longitudinal studies of individuals.