Underrepresented minority students receive lower grades and have higher rates of attrition across STEM disciplines: A sign of inequity?

Abstract

Underrepresented minority (URM) students are subjected to historically rooted inequities when pursuing an education, especially in STEM disciplines with little diversity. In order to make STEM education equitable and inclusive, evidence for how students from different racial/ethnic demographics are faring is necessary. We use 10 years of institutional data at a large public US-based university to investigate trends in the majors that Asian, URM, and White students declare, drop, and complete. We find that URM students drop most majors at higher rates compared to other students, particularly in physics and economics. We find alarming GPA trends in that URM students consistently earn lower grades than their Asian and White peers. In some STEM disciplines, the URM students who earn a degree are earning the same grades as the Asian and White students who dropped the major. These troubling trends may signify lack of sufficient support, mentoring, and guidance for the URM students who are already severely disadvantaged particularly at a primarily White institution. These findings call for greater resources and effort for making learning environments equitable and inclusive so that many URM students who come to college with severe disadvantages are appropriately supported and can excel similar to other students.

Integrating Critical Approaches into Quantitative STEM Equity Work

“…A popular practice in STEM equity research is to observe the achievement gaps existing between majority and marginalized and minoritized students (Gouvea, 2021). A wealth of research explores how students who belong to underserved racial, gender, ability, and socioeconomic groups underperform academically in comparison to their privileged counterparts (e.g., Bastedo and Jaquette, 2011;Matz et al, 2017;Whitcomb and Singh, 2021). Focusing solely on gaps is harmful, because it centers students' identities as the reasons behind their academic failures.…”

Relative Impact of Values-Oriented and Mindset-Oriented Interventions on Academic Success of Introductory Biology Students Attending 2-Year or 4-Year Institutions

“…degree is to complete the prerequisite introductory STEM courses. Unfortunately, numerous studies document significant achievement gaps in introductory course success, and subsequent attrition rates, for women and minoritized students in mathematical, physical, and biological sciences degree programs ( 9 – 15 ).…”

Comparing Major Declaration, Attrition, Migration, and Completion in Physics With Other STEM Disciplines: A Sign of Inequitable Physics Culture?

“…Previously we investigated inequities in learning for ethnic and racial minority (ERM) students in STEM disciplines using 10 years of institutional data (Whitcomb et al, 2021). We found that ERM students drop most STEM majors at higher rates compared to other students.…”