Understanding the attitudes and acceptability of extra-genital Chlamydia testing in young women: evaluation of a feasibility study

Abstract

Background Chlamydia trachomatis (C. trachomatis) is the most common bacterial sexually transmitted infection in the UK. Recent studies suggest that in addition to the genital tract, C. trachomatis is found in the throat and rectum, suggesting the number of infections is under-reported. There is an urgent need to study the impact of extending diagnosis to include extra-genital samples; however, there is a lack of evidence on the acceptability of asking young women to provide these samples. Method A mixed methods single group feasibility study explored the acceptability of combined genital and extra-genital testing in young women aged 16–25 years consecutively attending a sexual health centre in Edinburgh, Scotland. Young women were asked to complete a self- administered anonymous questionnaire whether they would be willing to give self-taken throat and ano-rectal samples. Interviews with women ( n = 20) willing to self-sample were conducted before and after self-sampling, and these explored the underlying reasons behind their decision, and feelings about the tests. Results Of 500 women recruited to the study, 422 (84.4%) women provided sufficient data for analysis. From completed questionnaires, 86.3% of respondents reported willingness to self-sample from the throat. Willingness of ano-rectal self-sampling was lower (59.1%), particularly in women under 20 (< 20 years: 44.4%; ≥20 years, 68.2%). Willingness of ano-rectal self-sampling was higher in women who had more sexual partners in the last 6 months (0 partners, 48.3%, n = 14, 3 or more partners, 67.4%, n = 60) and in those who have previous experience of a positive test for a sexually transmitted infection (STI) (positive: 64.5%; negative: 57%). Interviewed women suggested that a lack of knowledge of STIs, embarrassment and lack of confidence in the ability to carry out the sampling were barriers towards acceptability. Conclusions In this study, self-sampling of throat samples is largely acceptable; however, the acceptability of taking an ano-rectal sample for C. trachomatis testing in young women was lower in younger women. The study suggests further research to investigate the acceptability of extra-genital testing as an addition to routine C. trachomatis testing, and whether this increases detection and prevents infective sequelae for women. Electronic supplementary material The online version of this article (10.1186/s12889-019-7313-0) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Feasibility of anorectal chlamydia testing in women: a cross-sectional survey among general practitioners

“…For example, barriers that relate to the patient, laboratory services or financial aspects of testing were not taken examined here, but may be of influence. The GP-anticipated acceptability of anorectal testing was high for both self-collection and/or provider collection, in line with previous acceptability estimates from patients themselves (30,31). Twenty nine percent of GPs, however, nevertheless opposed to anorectal CT testing on a routine basis in women with an indication for CT testing.…”

Patient Demographics and the Utilization of a Novel 3-Anatomic-Site Testing Panel Including Rectal Self-Collection as Compared With Usual Care Testing

“…Other potential reasons for this incongruity may include lack of knowledge of STIs, embarrassment, or lack of confidence in the ability to carry out the self-swabbing. 15 Revised CDC guidelines for 2021 have expanded testing for rectal and pharyngeal sites for women only if they report sexual behaviors to their providers. Expanding national guidelines to include all women regardless of reported sexual behaviors may help increase utilization of the 3-site testing panel among women.…”

Update your “sore throat” differential list: A case report and discussion of oral chlamydia

“…Evidence demonstrates that self-collected oropharyngeal and anorectal swabs were concordant with provider-collected samples, suggesting that this as a reliable testing method (Chohonis et al, 2020). Interviewed women reported embarrassment and lack of confidence in their ability to carry out self-sampling, particularly in women <20 years old and with anorectal sampling (Brown et al, 2019).…”