The present study demonstrates a common behaviour of a forced nonlinear structure with smooth nonlinearity, while coupled dynamics are apparent, originating from the attached electrodynamic shaker. This appears as a variation in the transmitted forcing amplitude and is often subjected to a hysteretic (multi-state) behaviour for up and down open-loop sweeping. This situation differs from the ideal constant amplitude harmonic excitation, on which parameter extraction and engineering comprehension are based on. Untreated or ignored, this can lead to the misinterpretation of the underlying dynamics through the measured nonlinear frequency response curves and their force-normalised version, often called quasi-frequency response function. In this paper, a post-processing solution is introduced for the correct interpretation of frequency response curves at constant forcing amplitudes through the open-loop construction and resectioning of the so-called frequency response surface. The phenomenon and the proposed methodology are demonstrated using a two-degrees-of-freedom model on a shaker-nonlinear beam structure. First, open-loop frequency sweeps are executed on the mechanical system to create the nonlinear frequency response surface, where their actual amplitudes and hysteresis widths are significantly different from the ideal constant forcing amplitude case. The response surface is then sectioned at the assumed constant forcing values by using an appropriate interpolation law. These resectioned curves represent the forced nonlinear standalone structure under ideal constant harmonic excitation. The frequency response surfaces are characterised and resectioned on a nonlinear structure with stiffening and softening cases. Furthermore, an improvement in the operational resonance decay (ORD) method in its filtering and automation is shown to extract the backbone curves (BBCs). The BBC and the resectioned surface provide a complete picture and cross-validation of the underlying dynamics. Finally, the BBC and its distortion are also shown in the response surfaces in relation with the excitation normalization.