Limpet teeth are striking examples of a biological fibrous nanocomposite consisting of goethite mineral within a polymeric chitin matrix. The mechanical function of limpet teeth is critically dependent on the efficient composite behaviour of goethite, formed as distinct discontinuous nanofibres, reinforcing the matrix. The mechanical properties of discrete volumes from a limpet tooth measured using atomic force microscopy indicate how the tooth structure can be approximated as a short fibre-reinforced composite. Short fibre composite analysis reveals how the goethite nanofibres have a length optimized for the transfer of stress from the matrix to fibre and highlight how this limpet tooth structure is efficient in a mechanical load-bearing function.