Understanding the relationship between self‐reported offending and official criminal charges across early adulthood

Abstract

Background There has been very little research examining criminal careers in adulthood using both self-report data and official records. Aims The aims of this paper are to use self-reports and official criminal records to explore (1) the prevalences and frequencies of offending behaviour in adulthood; (2) continuity in offending behaviour across the life course; and (3) predictors of official court charges in adulthood. Method Data are drawn from the Seattle Social Development Project (SSDP), a longitudinal study of 808 participants followed from childhood into early adulthood. Data from ages 21 through 33 are used to examine criminal careers. Results Prevalences of offending behaviour decreased with age, while frequency among offenders remained stable or increased. There was significant continuity in offending from adolescence to adulthood in both self-reports and official records, especially for violence. Violent offences were most likely to result in a court charge. Even after controlling for self-reported frequency of offending, demographic variables (gender, ethnicity, and poverty) were significantly related to a court charge. Conclusions Self-report and official records, both separately and together, provide valuable information for understanding criminal careers in adulthood, especially with regard to offending continuity across the life course and predicting the likelihood of a court charge.

The Adolescence–Adulthood Transition and Desistance from Crime: Examining the Underlying Structure of Desistance

“…More experienced offenders will under-report their offenses, especially serious and violent offenses for fear of reprisal. Furthermore, Gilman et al [26] recently showed that the prevalence of the continuity of offending was actually higher for official data compared to self-report data. Farrington et al [23] reported that the age of desistance was generally later according to convictions.…”

Trends in the Perpetration of Physical Aggression among Norwegian Adolescents 2007–2015

“…Perpetration of aggressive acts in adolescence can have long-lasting negative impacts that affect later life. For example, perpetrators have a greater risk of dropping out of college compared with other youth (Jennings et al 2011), and they more often participate in later violent and nonviolent crimes (Gilman et al 2014). Furthermore, problem behavior in general, which includes physical aggression, is related to future economic difficulties, drug problems, and poor mental and physical health (Odgers et al 2008).…”

The effect of being left home alone at age 3 years on schizotypy and antisocial behavior at ages 17 and 23 years

“…Data were available on 1253 individuals. In Mauritius, 32.1% self-reported one or more crimes at age 23 years while 5.2% had one or more official crime records, a level somewhat lower than U.S. rates (52.8% and 6.2% respectively (Gilman et al, 2014).…”