Understanding the Role of Healthy Eating and Fitness Mobile Apps in the Formation of Maladaptive Eating and Exercise Behaviors in Young People

Abstract

BackgroundHealthy eating and fitness mobile apps are designed to promote healthier living. However, for young people, body dissatisfaction is commonplace, and these types of apps can become a source of maladaptive eating and exercise behaviors. Furthermore, such apps are designed to promote continuous engagement, potentially fostering compulsive behaviors.ObjectiveThe aim of this study was to identify potential risks around healthy eating and fitness app use and negative experience and behavior formation among young people and to inform the understanding around how current commercial healthy eating and fitness apps on the market may, or may not, be exasperating such behaviors.MethodsOur research was conducted in 2 phases. Through a survey (n=106) and 2 workshops (n=8), we gained an understanding of young people’s perceptions of healthy eating and fitness apps and any potential harm that their use might have; we then explored these further through interviews with experts (n=3) in eating disorder and body image. Using insights drawn from this initial phase, we then explored the degree to which leading apps are preventing, or indeed contributing to, the formation of maladaptive eating and exercise behaviors. We conducted a review of the top 100 healthy eating and fitness apps on the Google Play Store to find out whether or not apps on the market have the potential to elicit maladaptive eating and exercise behaviors.ResultsParticipants were aged between 18 and 25 years and had current or past experience of using healthy eating and fitness apps. Almost half of our survey participants indicated that they had experienced some form of negative experiences and behaviors through their app use. Our findings indicate a wide range of concerns around the wider impact of healthy eating and fitness apps on individuals at risk of maladaptive eating and exercise behavior, including (1) guilt formation because of the nature of persuasive models, (2) social isolation as a result of personal regimens around diet and fitness goals, (3) fear of receiving negative responses when targets are not achieved, and (4) feelings of being controlled by the app. The app review identified logging functionalities available across the apps that are used to promote the sustained use of the app. However, a significant number of these functionalities were seen to have the potential to cause negative experiences and behaviors.ConclusionsIn this study, we offer a set of responsibility guidelines for future researchers, designers, and developers of digital technologies aiming to support healthy eating and fitness behaviors. Our study highlights the necessity for careful considerations around the design of apps that promote weight loss or body modification through fitness training, especially when they are used by young people who are vulnerable to the development of poor body image and maladaptive eating and exercise behaviors.

Young People’s Use of Digital Health Technologies in the Global North: Narrative Review

“…They liked apps that were free, easy to use, provided visual and auditory cues, and had game-like rewards, but they did not want to link the apps to social media [ 48 ]. Findings from an English study that involved a survey, workshops, and interviews with young people aged 18 to 25 years showed that a calorie-counting app was the most popular and was used by almost half of the participants [ 49 ]. Many participants had discontinued using a health or fitness app, however, citing lack of interest, time, or motivation as reasons.…”

Status of the research in fitness apps: A bibliometric analysis

“…Some articles focus on the problems related to fitness apps and the adherence to hegemonic beauty canons. In this line of research, Honary et al (2019) concluded that the use of these apps might increase social pressure to achieve unrealistic beauty ideals and could thus increase the incidence of eating problems, such as anorexia or excessive physical exercise. Another issue of concern relates to the privacy of and the large amount of personal data collected by these apps ( Adhikari et al, 2014 ).…”

Investigating Food Quality at Uum’s Lake Restaurant: Are Customers Satisfied?

“…According to Honary et al (2019), "results show that, ironically, people are more likely to make dietary decisions when there is a nutritious object than when there is not." Nutritious choices are increasingly favored, and 72 percent of customers choose to be healthier while dining outside their homes, such as in grocery stores like restaurants (Cohen & Babey, 2012).…”