Nitrogen-containing organic compounds, such as a-amino acids and alkaloids, are important biologically active compounds, thus the development of efficient and enantioselective methods for the construction of carbon-nitrogen bonds is a fundamental goal in modern organic synthesis.[1] Transitionmetal-catalyzed carbene insertion into N À H bonds is one of the most efficient methods to construct carbon-nitrogen bonds [2] and the development of asymmetric versions of the NÀH insertion reaction has attracted considerable attention. [3] In initial studies, chiral dirhodium catalysts were tested in intramolecular [4] and intermolecular [5] NÀH insertion reactions, however, only low to modest enantioselectivities (< 50 % ee) were achieved. Since these reports, other transition metals including copper and silver have been used as catalysts, and gave enantioselectivities up to 48 % ee.[6]Recently, we reported a highly enantioselective NÀH insertion reaction (up to 98 % ee) using a copper complex with chiral spiro bisoxazoline ligands.[7] Subsequently, two other types of chiral copper catalysts have been developed, one with a planar chiral bipyridine ligand [8] and the other with a binolderivative ligand, [9] and both of these catalysts give high enantioselectivities in NÀH insertion reactions.Although progress on copper-catalyzed asymmetric NÀH insertion reactions has been substantial, they still have serious limitations. For instance, all the copper-catalyzed N À H insertion reactions require high catalyst loading (5-10 mol %) for satisfactory yields and enantioselectivities, thus more-efficient chiral catalysts are highly desirable. Because the activity of dirhodium(II) catalysts is usually superior to that of copper catalysts in nonenantioselective NÀ H insertion reactions, [10] the possibility of using dirhodium catalysts to achieve highly enantioselective N À H insertion reactions is an intriguing one. Recently, Saito et al. [11] reported that dirhodium(II) carboxylates and cinchona alkaloids cooperatively catalyze the asymmetric NÀH insertion reactions of a-diazo-a-arylacetates with anilines. The combined catalysts exhibit excellent reactivity but only modest enantioselectivity (up to 71 % ee).
It is generally accepted that the rhodium-catalyzed N À H insertion most likely proceeds via an ylide intermediate (Scheme 1 A).[2a] We speculated that the subsequent protontransfer step could be facilitated by a chiral phosphoric acid [12] species via a seven-membered-ring transition state, and that, consequently, chiral induction could be accomplished in this step (Scheme 1 B). The groups of Yu [13] and Platz [14] have reported that either water or alcohols can assist proton transfer in OÀH insertion reactions, as indicated by density functional theory calculations and ultrafast time-resolved IR spectroscopy studies. These studies stimulated our interest in exploring asymmetric N À H insertion in the presence of a proton-transfer catalyst. As part of our ongoing work on the development of asymmetric carbene insertion reaction...