The production of hydrogen from water with semiconductor photocatalysts can be promoted by adding small amounts of metals to their surfaces. The resulting enhancement in photocatalytic activity is commonly attributed to a fast transfer of the excited electrons generated by photon absorption from the semiconductor to the metal, a step that prevents deexcitation back to the ground electronic state. Here we provide experimental evidence that suggests an alternative pathway that does not involve electron transfer to the metal but requires it to act as a catalyst for the recombination of the hydrogen atoms made via the reduction of protons on the surface of the semiconductor instead.photocatalysis | hydrogen production | gold-titania | time-resolved fluorescence | core-shell nanostructures P hotocatalysis is a promising technology to address problems in chemical synthesis (1), environmental remediation (2, 3), and energy utilization (4). The potential for harvesting solar energy and storing it as a chemical fuel using photocatalysts is particularly appealing. Specifically, H 2 may be produced via water splitting this way (5-7). In fact, many photocatalysts have been reported already capable of producing hydrogen out of water, even if none of those are yet commercially viable. Such photocatalysis rely on capturing photon energy via excitation of electrons from the valence band to the conduction band of appropriate semiconductors such as titania, which is often cited as a prototypical example (8-10), creating an excited electron-hole pair that is then used to promote redox reactions (11,12). However, for the photocatalysts to be useful, the lifetime of the electron-hole pair needs to be long enough to be accessible for chemical conversions. The search for photocatalytic systems that fulfill this and other key requirements continues, and would be greatly facilitated by a clearer understanding of the underlying chemical process.It is well known that the addition of metals such as platinum or gold to semiconductors enhances their activity as photocatalysts, in particular for water splitting to produce H 2 (13-15). This effect is currently explained by a mechanism where the excited electrons produced by absorption of light are transferred from the semiconductor to the metal before they have the opportunity to recombine with their corresponding holes and return to the ground electronic state (Fig. 1A) (16-18). In this scheme, the protons from water are reduced on the surface of the metal, in sites physically separated from those on the semiconductor, where oxygen production takes place. Here we present evidence that challenges this conventional explanation, and offer an alternative mechanism for the promotion of photocatalysis by metals. Specifically, using the Au/TiO 2 metal-semiconductor pair as a model system, we show that electron transfer to the metal may not play a significant role in photocatalysis. Instead, the data support a model where the excited electron promotes the reduction of protons on the surface of the se...