This is a short, light spirited account of how some possibly important science actually happened. It very much conflicts with Popper's contention that the key to scientific progress is falsification.Savas Dimopoulos is always enthusiastic about something, and in the spring of 1981 it was supersymmetry. He was visiting the new Institute for Theoretical Physics in Santa Barbara, which I had recently joined. We hit it off immediately -he was bursting with wild ideas, and I liked to stretch my mind by trying to take them seriously.Supersymmetry was (and is) a beautiful mathematical idea. It extends the symmetry of special relativity. Special relativity postulates the invariance of physical law under motion with a constant velocity. It thereby allows us to transform between objects with different speeds and to predict the properties of moving particles from those of stationary ones. Supersymmetry postulates the invariance of physical law under certain kinds of motion in a quantum-mechanical extension of space-time, superspace. Superspace has four extra quantum-mechanical dimensions, quite different from the familiar four dimensions of space and time. When a particle "moves" in the extra quantum dimensions it just acquires a tiny amount of angular momentum, or spin. So you wouldn't want to live in the new suburbs of superspace: it's very cramped, and makes you dizzy. But the mathematics of supersymmetry promised (and still promises) to help us unify fundamental physics: it allows us to transform between objects of different spin. Several different kinds of particles, differing in their spin, could be manifestations of a single entity moving at different speeds through superspace.The problem with applying supersymmetry is that it's too good for this world. We simply don't find particles of the sort it predicts. We don't, for example, see particles with the same charge and mass as electrons, but a different amount of spin. * This is, in essence, a solicited "Turning Points" feature written for Nature. It appeared, in a slightly abbreviated form, in the March 18 issue.