We study totally positive definite quadratic forms over the ring of integers O K of a totally real biquadratic field K = Q( √ m, √ s). We restrict our attention to classical forms (i.e., those with all non-diagonal coefficients in 2O K ) and prove that no such forms in three variables are universal (i.e., represent all totally positive elements of O K ). This provides further evidence towards Kitaoka's conjecture that there are only finitely many number fields over which such forms exist.One of our main tools are additively indecomposable elements of O K ; we prove several new results about their properties.